tougher matchup for Floyd, Cotto or JMM??

[JM1]

voted cotto

[Horus]

cotto does nothing better than JMM period.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

cotto does nothing better than JMM period.

Sure, Calderon is a way better boxer than JMM and Cotto toghether, does this mean Floyd should fight him then?

Damn Horus is back with is ****!!!!!!

[Horus]

Sure, Calderon is a way better boxer than JMM and Cotto toghether, does this mean Floyd should fight him then?

Damn Horus is back with is ****!!!!!!

Wrong ivan calderon is not better than JMM...
And Ivan calderon didnt challenge Mayweather to a fight..

JMM is a great fighter who is better than cotto period.
He brings more to the table from a fighting standpoint. than cotto could ever bring.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Wrong ivan calderon is not better than JMM...
And Ivan calderon didnt challenge Mayweather to a fight..

JMM is a great fighter who is better than cotto period.
He brings more to the table from a fighting standpoint. than cotto could ever bring.

Margarito and paul Williams did, so whats up with them?

they dont count because they are WWs?

Cotto and JMM are as good, but JMM is actually a 130lber!!

[Horus]

Margarito and paul Williams did, so whats up with them?

they dont count because they are WWs?

Cotto and JMM are as good, but JMM is actually a 130lber!!

Margarito is a confirmed cheater
I have every reason to believe that he has gotten to where he was because he cheated...

In 2006 who was Margarito?
but a unknown cheater..

Who was Paul Williams in 2006?

get real

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Margarito is a confirmed cheater
I have every reason to believe that he has gotten to where he was because he cheated...

In 2006 who was Margarito?
but a unknown cheater..

Who was Paul Williams in 2006?

get real

We are talking about now, 2009.

Why he dont face guys in his own division?

[Horus]

We are talking about now, 2009.

Why he dont face guys in his own division?

the same reason cotto doesnt...

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

the same reason cotto doesnt...

Margarito, Mosley,Quintana,Clottey arent WWs?

Ok good!!!!!

[tesla_power]

Wrong ivan calderon is not better than JMM...
And Ivan calderon didnt challenge Mayweather to a fight..

JMM is a great fighter who is better than cotto period.
He brings more to the table from a fighting standpoint. than cotto could ever bring.

I agree only that the skillset of JMM is greater than Cotto. IMO, this is the reason why he is able to KO both Casamayor and Diaz even though he is the smaller fighter. But Cotto is no mediocre fighter. He is arguably the current best WW ( debatable but still he is either no 1 or no 2 at this point ). Let's just say Cotto is good while JMM is great. But factor in the the size and you could come up with a more logical idea than Cotto is tougher matchup than Jmm.

If you ask who do I think would win between Floyd and Cotto, I would lean towards Floyd. But until Floyd gets in the ring with him, this would not be answered.

IMO, You cannot just subgroup a fighter's attributes and look at each attributes individually. This is no math class. In boxing, the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.