tougher matchup for Floyd, Cotto or JMM??

[Horus]

JMM is all around better fighter than Cotto. Your question is not going to get answer because it can't. In the skill department, JMM has it over Cotto.

the fact is they know this.. but the problem is..
who ever floyd fights his critics will say he should be fighting somebody else.

even when the fighter he is fighting THE #2 FIGHTER IN THE WORLD

[Pullcounter]

1. What does floyd weigh on fight night
2. What division and where has majority of floyd fights taken place?
3. John Ruiz had more size and power than Tarver and he lost to Roy Jones and Tarver beat roy jones...
4. You are saying Cotto is a better matchup base on size not skill, but who is close in size Floyd Mayweather and Juan Marquez ....when
90% of Mayweather career has been at 135 and under...90% !!!!
what does that meaned to you guys????

Context
The WW Division

Cotto's: 2nd Division
Margarito's: 2nd Division
Shane Mosley: 3rd Division
Andre Berto: 2nd Division (1st:160)
Joshua Clottey:1st Division
Kermit Cintron: 1st Division
Paul Williams:2nd Division (1st:160)
CarlosQuintana:1st Division
Floyd Mayweather 4th Division

The welterweight division is floyd's 4th Divison and would be JMM 5th..

Name 1 welterweight floyd is bigger then??


With this said...dont act JMM is fighting a Margarito type welterweight
Juan M. Marquez is fighting Floyd Mayweather a blown up Lightweight. and the smallest welterweight in the division.

See the problem is people got used to floyd fighting bigger fighters all the time, that when he fights somebody his own size or smaller therE is now a problem...

Good points as always, but if pbf campaigns at WW, shouldn't he be fighting WWs???

[Brandish]

It has to be Cotto. He is a big puncher and he pressures most of the fime unless hurt which I think will bother Money. Too much pressure while JMM is a smaller guy naturally and will allow Floyd to work a little more because of his counter puncher style.

when has cotto ever pressured an elite fighter. he ran in every big fight he had..cotto will hop on his bike as soon as floyd starts tagging him. as big as cotto is he sucks as being a pressure fighter and his chin sucks

[shogunn]

1. What does floyd weigh on fight night
2. What division and where has majority of floyd fights taken place?
3. John Ruiz had more size and power than Tarver and he lost to Roy Jones and Tarver beat roy jones...
4. You are saying Cotto is a better matchup base on size not skill, but who is close in size Floyd Mayweather and Juan Marquez ....when
90% of Mayweather career has been at 135 and under...90% !!!!
what does that meaned to you guys????

Context
The WW Division

Cotto's: 2nd Division
Margarito's: 2nd Division
Shane Mosley: 3rd Division
Andre Berto: 2nd Division (1st:160)
Joshua Clottey:1st Division
Kermit Cintron: 1st Division
Paul Williams:2nd Division (1st:160)
CarlosQuintana:1st Division
Floyd Mayweather 4th Division

The welterweight division is floyd's 4th Divison and would be JMM 5th..

Name 1 welterweight floyd is bigger then??


With this said...dont act JMM is fighting a Margarito type welterweight
Juan M. Marquez is fighting Floyd Mayweather a blown up Lightweight. and the smallest welterweight in the division.

See the problem is people got used to floyd fighting bigger fighters all the time, that when he fights somebody his own size or smaller therE is now a problem...

are you a ****in idiot, you just almost completley ignored everything I said. This is getting just ******. Now youre claiming Mayweather is lightweight. oh god....

[Horus]

Ok...

So JMM has a better skillset than Cotto, but what your missing is the most important part that you seem to be purposedly neglecting is..

JMM is 35 now, and moving up in weight.

What's skill when you can't use it effectly anymore? Ok I think most people agree whos better skill-wise but if you can't use it right at increased weight who's the tougher fight now?

I guess Joe calzaghe, Hopkins,Mosley,Geln Johnson skillsets is were **** too when they moved at a higher aged.

Floyd mayweather is not 24,25,26,27 he is 32 years old.turning 33
he is aged too...and he is moving down in weight.

What hurts a fighter more.. Moving up in weight when they get older..
or moving down in weight when they get older?

So thier is the points right there

[Deja_Vous]

Simple as that. JMM coming from 135 or Cotto at 147.

Mayweather fans are now saying JMM is tougher fight rather than Cotto. Apparently Mosley stomped Margarito who beat Cotto, thus cotto = ****???

Fanny Pac should be fighting Shane instead of the freshly KO'd Cotto.

[shogunn]

Fanny Pac should be fighting Shane instead of the freshly KO'd Cotto.

So should Floyd over JMM. too bad floyd is a bigger vagina than everyone else.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=274306

[Mojita]

I guess Joe calzaghe, Hopkins,Mosley,Geln Johnson skillsets is were **** too when they moved at a higher aged.

Floyd mayweather is not 24,25,26,27 he is 32 years old.turning 33
he is aged too...and he is moving down in weight.

What hurts a fighter more.. Moving up in weight when they get older..
or moving down in weight when they get older?

So thier is the points right there

JMM isn't any of those fighters at all so to compare and say just because someone did means that he's going to isn't a valid point just a biased opinon so you can just say the fight is validated a toughter fighter for Floyd. and BTW those guys you mentioned their body frames carried the weight well.

Point blank - JMM isn't proven at 140 and he's going to fight where 142, 143? Almost 10 pounds up from 135 after he spent most of his career at 130 and under and moving up at a advanced age. And yes Floyd is coming down but he isn't coming down so much where he's going to be completely drained at all. and he's still fresh - he came out retirement.

[Brandish]

Fanny Pac should be fighting Shane instead of the freshly KO'd Cotto.

they dred the thought of pac ever fighting a black champion. he ducked guzman at 130, campbell at 135, bradley at 140, and now shane at 147

[Brandish]

Point blank - JMM isn't proven at 140 and he's going to fight where 142, 143? Almost 10 pounds up from 135 after he spent most of his career at 130 and under and moving up at a advanced age. And yes Floyd is coming down but he isn't coming down so much where he's going to be completely drained at all. and he's still fresh - he came out retirement.

when shane jumped from 135 to 147 to beat oscar he wsn't proven at the weight.

floyd jumped from 130 to 135 straight into a title fight no tuneup he did it again at 154 no tuneup straight into a tiutle fight against the best champions in castillo and de la hoya..

I fail to see your point.