I like how Cotto fans mention every fighter...

[TheGreatA]

Hatton was ranked at WW when fought beat him. He was a Top 5 WW at the time. Baldomir and Judah were 1 and 2. And Oscar was Number 1 Jr MW


Margarito is meaningless for Cotto fans after he embarrassed him and KO’d Cotto

By your logic Hatton is a light welterweight so it shouldn't count and Mayweather "struggled" against Judah (as Clottey supposedly did).

I don't think Hatton was a top 5 WW at the time. Can you prove this?

http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.ph...rweight--2000s

Ring magazine ratings at the end of 2008 (before Mosley KO'd Margarito):

1. Antonio Margarito
2. Miguel Angel Cotto
3. Shane Mosley
4. Joshua Clottey
5. Manny Pacquiao
6. Carlos Quintana
7. Zab Judah
8. Luis Collazo
9. Andre Berto
10. Isaac Hlatshwayo

Cotto has fought/will fight everyone in the top 7.

[Rich Loc]

He would have a better case IF he had stayed at welterweight and defended his title against solid contenders. Instead he decided to move up in weight and from what it seems the move up in weight will likely be permanent.

Let’s get the fact correct at least.

He called out Cotto after Margarito win. Cotto beat Mosley. But Williams realized Cotto wasn’t going to fight him so he fought Carlos Q

Clottey-Cotto didn’t happen because HBO didn’t want to put up the funds.

Margarito ducked a 4 million guaranteed for Mosley instead of fighting for the ring title

Mosley wants no part of Williams

[THE REED]

Hatton was ranked at WW when fought beat him. He was a Top 5 WW at the time. Baldomir and Judah were 1 and 2. And Oscar was Number 1 Jr MW


Margarito is meaningless for Cotto fans after he embarrassed him and KO’d Cotto

Hatton was not ranked at WW at ALL...

[JAB5239]

Hatton was ranked at WW when fought beat him. He was a Top 5 WW at the time. Baldomir and Judah were 1 and 2. And Oscar was Number 1 Jr MW

How was Hatton a ranked welter at that time? He hadn't fought at that weight in a year and a half after struggling with Collazo and reliquished his title to move back to 140 where he fought twice before moving back up for Floyd.

Baldomir was a journeyman and Judah lost to him. Obviously neither were that good and nither has beaten a top level fighter since.

Margarito is meaningless for Cotto fans after he embarrassed him and KO’d Cotto

He won, he didn't embarass him. And he still has that cloud of su****ion hanging over his head.

[dans]

Hatton was not ranked at WW at ALL...

Correct Hatton had moved back to JWW for his two fights before Mayweather.

[boxasmash]

Interesting, how ranking is important now. When Floyd fought Baldomir for ring title he was ****ed on for that. Yet ok to fight Margarito's leftover not hois conquererer



Which one of the two beat Maragrito??

knew it.

you never liked williams, you just use him as a ploy to defend mayweather.

[Rich Loc]

By your logic Hatton is a light welterweight so it shouldn't count and Mayweather "struggled" against Judah (as Clottey supposedly did).

I don't think Hatton was a top 5 WW at the time. Can you prove this?

http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.ph...rweight--2000s

Ring magazine ratings at the end of 2008:

1. Antonio Margarito
2. Miguel Angel Cotto
3. Shane Mosley
4. Joshua Clottey
5. Manny Pacquiao
6. Carlos Quintana
7. Zab Judah
8. Luis Collazo
9. Andre Berto
10. Isaac Hlatshwayo

Cotto has fought/will fight everyone in the top 7.

That's the end of 2008.

Mayweather fought Hatton at the end of 2007. Hatton was on the ranking but dropped right after his loss, because he said he was going to back to Jr WW

[Rich Loc]

knew it.

you never liked williams, you just use him as a ploy to defend mayweather.

American fans can’t support other American fighters. OK got that

[Xplosivo]

He won, he didn't embarass him. And he still has that cloud of su****ion hanging over his head.

Who is cotto fighting next?

did that "journeyman" happen to beat the fighter cotto is fighting next? apart from that gatti and judah too? that journeyman can say proudly he was the linear welterweight champion/ the 1 recognised welterweight/unified champ. something cotto never can...instead cotto always fights for vacant belts whether at 140 and 147...these are FACTS

[Rich Loc]

He won, he didn't embarass him. And he still has that cloud of su****ion hanging over his head.

Taking two knees against a guy who you were favourite to beat

I call that weak