Is Calzaghe the Greatest of All Time?

[JulioCesaChavez]

Why didn't you take your medication ****y

[Underdog82]

I am a big Calzaghe fan, and I will tell you right now he is not the greatest of all time, that is ridiculous. Even though some will argue that he defeated an old Hopkins and Roy Jones, I feel in my gut that he would of come out victories had those fighters been in their primes as well. So I consider him an ATG, but not the best ATG. No, hes not that good.

[Dan...]

Why didn't you take your medication ****y

IS this yet another Rafael Benitez alt?

[Steak]

this whole thread is hilarious to me. I dont know why, but at this specific moment, theres nothing I would rather do than sit on a computer typing anonymously about overdiscussed boxing subjects. its great.

Julio Cesar Chavez's defence>Calzaghe's. no, really. Im dead serious.

[Wiley Hyena]

this whole thread is hilarious to me. I dont know why, but at this specific moment, theres nothing I would rather do than sit on a computer typing anonymously about overdiscussed boxing subjects. its great.

Julio Cesar Chavez's defence>Calzaghe's. no, really. Im dead serious.

ROFL! Agreed. I love boxing. God I love it so.

[Wiley Hyena]

I am a big Calzaghe fan, and I will tell you right now he is not the greatest of all time, that is ridiculous. Even though some will argue that he defeated an old Hopkins and Roy Jones, I feel in my gut that he would of come out victories had those fighters been in their primes as well. So I consider him an ATG, but not the best ATG. No, hes not that good.

Listen to your logic. You say Cal would have defeated Jones AND Hopkins in their primes. Now assuming this is true: Where does he rank as ATG? If that assumption is true, then Calzaghe is way, way, up there my friend.

[daggum]

Listen to your logic. You say Cal would have defeated Jones AND Hopkins in their primes. Now assuming this is true: Where does he rank as ATG? If that assumption is true, then Calzaghe is way, way, up there my friend.

calzaghes whole career is based on assumptions of what he could have done. pretty fricking sad.

[bsrizpac]

A prediction before the fight. You made it seem like I said that after the fight. Yes, I missed a prediction. If I got them all right, I would be a millionaire.

Kind of ****ing gay for you to call Floyd overrated after loudly and obnoxiously saying Hatton would destroy him.

[Truth]

Listen I don't like to be mean but, should Calzaghe even be in discussion as the G.O.A.T.? I personally do not believe so.

[Wiley Hyena]

Kind of ****ing gay for you to call Floyd overrated after loudly and obnoxiously saying Hatton would destroy him.

The problem is that Hatton was always overrated. I rooted for him nonetheless because he is pugnacious and will fight anybody. I admire that in a fighter.