Is Calzaghe the Greatest of All Time?

[daggum]

But, it is true, whether you like it or not. Won't you believe your lying eyes? In case you won't, then look at his record. Furthermore, IT IS A FACT that Calzaghe is both left and right handed.

yea im looking at his record he got dropped and hurt badly vs scrubs like mitchell and salem. do people with good chins have this happen? getting dropped by old men like roy jones and hopkins doesn't look too good. do people with good chins have this happen? did terry norris get dropped by an old leonard no. and we all know how great terry's chin is. FACE FACTS CALZAGHE'S CHIN IS HIGHLY SUSPECT.

[SonOfCuba]

I guess Ricardo Lopez is better than Roy Jones, that sucks men.

[roundingace]

Mayweather has a fine defense, but IMO it's not as good as Calzaghe's for the reasons I've already stated.

Lol ok. Mayweather, as someone pointed out, hasn't taken many hard shots his WHOLE career! But yeah, JC's MUST be better. Sigh.
Defense: FMJr > JC

[Steak]

Mayweather has a fine defense, but IMO it's not as good as Calzaghe's for the reasons I've already stated.

hehe.

is Calzaghe's defence better than...James Toney, Nicolino Locche, Pernell Whitaker, Wilfred Benitez, Bernard Hopkins, Willie Pep, etc?

[Wiley Hyena]

yea im looking at his record he got dropped and hurt badly vs scrubs like mitchell and salem. do people with good chins have this happen? getting dropped by old men like roy jones and hopkins doesn't look too good. do people with good chins have this happen? did terry norris get dropped by an old leonard no. and we all know how great terry's chin is. FACE FACTS CALZAGHE'S CHIN IS HIGHLY SUSPECT.

Mitchell??? That's just b.s. It just so happens that Cal got knocked down in the Mitchell fight and jumped right back up and knocked Mitchell down in the same round! Didn't look too hurt to me.

[daggum]

Mayweather has a fine defense, but IMO it's not as good as Calzaghe's for the reasons I've already stated.

i thought calzaghe was frickin willie pep the other night. whitaker came out and said this man stole my D!

[Dynamite Kid]

hehe.

is Calzaghe's defence better than...James Toney, Nicolino Locche, Pernell Whitaker, Wilfred Benitez, Bernard Hopkins, Willie Pep, etc?

Gatti has a better defence than Calzaghe

[daggum]

Mitchell??? That's just b.s. It just so happens that Cal got knocked down in the Mitchell fight and jumped right back up and knocked Mitchell down in the same round! Didn't look too hurt to me.

wow how great! gets knocked down and badly hurt(obv you haven't seen it if you think he wasn't hurt) then knocks out the bum with a glass jaw. thanks to an early stoppage as well. if calzaghe wasn't hurt then surely mitchel wasn't either according to your malfunctioning brain.

[Vladimir303]

Seriuos question,


Is there a worse poster on NSB then the thread starter Wiley? If he was just trollin being sarcastic, ok......but this guy is actually serious with some of the nonsense he says.

Calzaghe's defence better then Mayweathers??? ROFL.

Time to move on, nothing constructive is gonna get done here.

[Wiley Hyena]

hehe.

is Calzaghe's defence better than...James Toney, Nicolino Locche, Pernell Whitaker, Wilfred Benitez, Bernard Hopkins, Willie Pep, etc?

I'm not saying Calzaghe was the greatest. I'm making an argument in his behalf.

You guys have been pounding Calzaghe and his fans ever since he embarrassed RJJ. The problem is that.....they have something to say. The man is a special fighter....there is no doubt about it. As an American I have to admit this. It is what it is.