Would Calzaghe go through RJJ's resume undeafeated?

[Mrvooh]

At 168. he'd beat em all...at 175, maybe not

[Easy-E]

no. Toney, B-Hop and Ruiz would be L's.
McCallum, Griffin, Tarver and Johnson would be toss ups.

[IMDAZED]

no. Toney, B-Hop and Ruiz would be L's.
McCallum, Griffin, Tarver and Johnson would be toss ups.

McCallum was still formidable and wily at 40 but Joe C. beats him up.

[Patty Tanager]

he would have lost to:

toney, b-hop, ruiz, tarver, virgil hill, and McCallum

he would have 6 losses im pretty sure of, and two fights he may have lost in griffin and johnson

(this is assuming he started at roys weight and fought these guys when roy did)


at best he would have been 51-6

at worst 49-8

Ridiculous.

[Calzaghe - 50-0]

Calzaghe doen't lose...Of course he would have.

[Burner]

calzaghe would NEVER go through his whole resume undefeated...majority of all fighters wouldnt...

Hopkins...toney...glen johnson..tarver...ruiz at heavy.

[bsrizpac]

Calzaghe doen't lose...Of course he would have.

I'm so glad Joe is around so we can get amazing insight from his "fans". this stuff is comedy gold.

[Testdead]

The Toney that Roy fought and the Hopkins Roy fought would lose to Calzaghe.

Ruiz might be too big.

[ACHlLLES]

Who the **** knows? Personally I think he beats everyone even including Ruiz, but the toney,hopkins fights are questionable. Oh, and I will say this though... Something looked wrong with toney the night he fought roy. He looked fatter and out of shape? Maybe too much burger-king?

[THE REED]

Calzaghe going through Roys resume undefeated is questionable.

Roy going through Calzaghe's resume undefeated, is not.