Should Calzaghe be P4P number one in the RING rankings?

[Macho Madness]

Yeah the Aussies are generally good posters. Its a shame more of you goes from Aussie Lounge don't post in NSB more often.

yeh i think there will b more since there like nuttin to talk bout there, so i might just flame in threads bout calzaghe hahaha

Good wholesome fun

[SHB]

You are measured by the quality of opposition you beat which is indicated by your resume. Do you understand?

I do. You clearly don't.

Resume is merely an indicator. Not the ****ing whole argument. DO YOU UNDERSTAND?

Argue that Pacquiao is P4P #1. I personally agree. But IT IS NOT ALL DECIDED BY RESUME. The clue's in the ****ing name!

[j.razor]

There have been numerous posts about how if Calzaghe were American he would be the P4P best fighter in the world and that it is because of his nationality he ranks as number two. Is this true?

not after Jones beats him...

[j.razor]

just to add to this statement when mayweather was named p4p1 he didnt have the accomplishments of joe calzaghe

yeah i know he had way more than cal-slappy...lol

[FUC_U_PAYME]

no he wont he be ranked lower then what he is now

[Dan...]

I do. You clearly don't.

Resume is merely an indicator. Not the ****ing whole argument. DO YOU UNDERSTAND?

Argue that Pacquiao is P4P #1. I personally agree. But IT IS NOT ALL DECIDED BY RESUME. The clue's in the ****ing name!

What I am saying that it is the calibre of opposition you beat that determines where you are placed on the p4p list. Your resume is a pretty much direct indicator of who you beat. If you like it would be more correct to say your short term resume determines your p4p ranking.

[Allucard]

yea and those numerous posts are either from nuthuggers or haters mocking calz. like clegg said, even if he was american he would still be at #2.

I am amazed as why you sig didn't yet led to an avalanche of Calzaghe is gay threads... Maybe no one thought of it yet? Oops lol. But seriously that attempt at **** sex by Calzaghe really is GaY.

[Allucard]

What I am saying that it is the calibre of opposition you beat that determines where you are placed on the p4p list. Your resume is a pretty much direct indicator of who you beat. If you like it would be more correct to say your short term resume determines your p4p ranking.

You mean if i beat 60 year old Ali and then George foreman also a senior citizen i can make a case for p4p king?

[Macho Madness]

I am amazed as why you sig didn't yet led to an avalanche of Calzaghe is gay threads... Maybe no one thought of it yet? Oops lol. But seriously that attempt at **** sex by Calzaghe really is GaY.

2 true mate 2 true

im sure he thought he was being smart but he just looked ****

[Dan...]

You mean if i beat 60 year old Ali and then George foreman also a senior citizen i can make a case for p4p king?

No, because the condition of those fighters when you beat them would be taken into account when considering your resume. Just like Ali's win over Archie Moore means ****; Joe's win over bernard means less than it would have a few years back; Camacho's win over Leonard means nothing; etc etc.