Should Calzaghe be P4P number one in the RING rankings?

[ALT-Assassin]

Calzaghe is at a solid No2. Pacman deserves to be at No1, but if Calzaghe beats Jones and then Pavlik, and Pac loses to De La Soul and Hatton, I would put Calzaghe up there.

I agree with this assessment

[shadeyfizzle]

Calzaghe wasnt even #2 when floyd was 1 and not too many Calzaghe fans had a problem with him being 3 but just because floyd retired he should get #1?? Doesnt work that way. Calzaghe's win over Hopkins just as if not more questionable than Pac's win over Marquez. But Pac has won another title in his 5th weightclass since and Calzaghe has yet to top that showing.

[ALT-Assassin]

Calzaghe wasnt even #2 when floyd was 1 and not too many Calzaghe fans had a problem with him being 3 but just because floyd retired he should get #1?? Doesnt work that way. Calzaghe's win over Hopkins just as if not more questionable than Pac's win over Marquez. But Pac has won another title in his 5th weightclass since and Calzaghe has yet to top that showing.

American bias is effecting boxing in a bad way.Fredie Roach only trains Manny because he is American and that is just wrong.

[shadeyfizzle]

American bias is effecting boxing in a bad way.Fredie Roach only trains Manny because he is American and that is just wrong.

And Calzaghe has been KTFO by Amir Khan so the Joe has never lost excuse is invalid. Lol

[El Dominicano]

Uhhh, everything, on pretty much every P4P list.

Hey 30k Clottey beats Margarito? You down??

[kayjay]

The RING is just a magazine that makes hypothetical rankings. Those rankings are meaningless.

I'm not going to tell a magazine run by fanboys like us how they should rank. I make my own rankings instead. Mine are just as valuable, which is to say worthless.

[T-97]

No,

He is deserving of the Number 2 Spot. But I think Pacquiao has earned his time at the top.

[BRAVE-HEART]

calzaghe is a weak *****

end thread/

[ALT-Assassin]

calzaghe is a weak *****

end thread/

Roy Jones is a weak ***** without roids

[BRAVE-HEART]

Roy Jones is a weak ***** without roids

Your mum is a weak ***** without roids

end thread/