Should Calzaghe be P4P number one in the RING rankings?

[SHB]

What has resume got to do with P4P?

I have Pacquiao #1 FWIW.

[Fox McCloud]

What has resume got to do with P4P?

I have Pacquiao #1 FWIW.

Uhhh, everything, on pretty much every P4P list.

[Clegg]

yea and those numerous posts are either from nuthuggers or haters mocking calz. like clegg said, even if he was american he would still be at #2.

Nice av.

I'm wearing my AC Milan shirt ATM. It's a few years old, and has Shevchenko on the back, so it's been looking out of date the past couple of years, but now that he's gone back suddenly my shirt is slightly more relevant

[Dan...]

What has resume got to do with P4P?

I have Pacquiao #1 FWIW.

Wtf do you mean what does resume have to do with p4p? What the **** kind of question is that?

[ElGranLuchador]

he would be number #1 if he was american
imagine if lacy cleaned out the division unified the titles defeated hopkins and still remained undefeated 45-0 the hype would be mad for this guy and the ring mag would buy it and put him at number 1

just to add to this statement when mayweather was named p4p1 he didnt have the accomplishments of joe calzaghe

[Fox McCloud]

AC MILAN FTW!

By the way, thanks for the complement danc.

[theghost#1]

Naw, Ring does have it right though. Manny #1 and Joe #2 is correct.

[Dan...]

just to add to this statement when mayweather was named p4p1 he didnt have the accomplishments of joe calzaghe

Could you please justify this statement? I would be pretty interested to hear it.

[ElGranLuchador]

i like ac milan but theyre gonna phail
its full of old past their prime guys
ronaldo ronaldinho kafu emerson maldini inzaghi
im surprised they didnt hire luis figo

[BetterCallSaul]

Calzaghe is at a solid No2. Pacman deserves to be at No1, but if Calzaghe beats Jones and then Pavlik, and Pac loses to De La Soul and Hatton, I would put Calzaghe up there.