what if: James Toney vs. Joe Calzaghe @ 168 (Prime for prime)

[pesticid]

James gets beaten up by Tibery and Thadzi, loses to Griffin twice, gets caught doing steroids, loses every single minute of every single round against Jones, but he would've somehow destroyed Zaghe?

Bunch of lunatics here I'll tell ya.

[aussieboxer2320]

toney would make him look like a novice

[pesticid]

toney would make him look like a novice

I guess

[aussieboxer2320]

even toney at heavyweight, fat washed up shadow of himself , no one can land big shots on him, hes had 80 fights, who else can say that nowadays besisdes some mexicans, hes an ATG for sure

[pesticid]

even toney at heavyweight, fat washed up shadow of himself , no one can land big shots on him, hes had 80 fights, who else can say that nowadays besisdes some mexicans, hes an ATG for sure

Nobody is saying otherwise.

[pesticid]

But Toney's eaten more leather in a fight than Calzaghe has eaten in his entire career.

[abadger]

But Toney's eaten more leather in a fight than Calzaghe has eaten in his entire career.

True. They won't admit it though.

[slicksouthpaw16]

James gets beaten up by Tibery and Thadzi, loses to Griffin twice, gets caught doing steroids, loses every single minute of every single round against Jones, but he would've somehow destroyed Zaghe?

Bunch of lunatics here I'll tell ya.

Yeah, all when he was out of shape. Thats like saying that Sedreck Fields would have still beaten an in shape and prepared Shannon Briggs on his best day. A fastasy match up is when both fighters are at their best, not choosing a fight where he looked his worst. Good job

[pesticid]

True. They won't admit it though.

I'll actually make a thread about it, see if anybody shows up.

[pesticid]

Yeah, all when he was out of shape. Thats like saying that Sedreck Fields would have still beaten an in shape and prepared Shannon Briggs on his best day. A fastasy match up is when both fighters are at their best, not choosing a fight where he looked his worst. Good job

Even at your worst you don't get beaten down like a dog.