Has Pacquiao surpassed Mayweather as the #1 P4P fighter

[JaNnO]

How, if its clear hes not as good as Floyd, and many people and sports writers had him losing to Marquez not once but twice now. Floyd is so good he isnt even given close fights, thats not his fault, hes just that far beyond people talent wise.

the same way many fight fans and sport scribes saw pacquiao winning both of them...you can't win there my friend.

the fact that the first fight was a draw (coz of a lousy judge giving 10-7 instead of 10-6 to pac in rd 1) and last night was a split draw...pacman owns superiority over marquez.

in the annals of boxing history...you and my comments don't count any thing. years from now what people will remember and new generations learn about these two fighters is but what OFFICIALLY transpired during those nights.

and you...yes you and the sour losers out there better learn to deal with it now.

[salinass1234]

I think Pacman is the #1 p4p fighter now...His resume and opposition is more impressive than Mayweather's.

I hate floyd but not only no but **** no. When mayweather fought the so called champions he beat the **** out out them. My not have been fan friendly but he did.

[salinass1234]

the same way many fight fans and sport scribes saw pacquiao winning both of them...you can't win there my friend.

the fact that the first fight was a draw (coz of a lousy judge giving 10-6 instead of 10-6 to pac in rd 1) and ;ast night was a split draw...pacman owns superiority over marquez.

in the annals of boxing history...you and my comments don't count any thing. years from now what people will remember and new generations learn about these two fighters is but what OFFICIALLY transpired during those nights.

and you...yes you and the sour losers out there better learn to deal with it now.

Your a ****en nut hugger. PAC clearly hit JMM when he was down so call it even. He was lucky not to get Disqualified or a point taken away.

[J_CON]

How, if its clear hes not as good as Floyd, and many people and sports writers had him losing to Marquez not once but twice now. Floyd is so good he isnt even given close fights, thats not his fault, hes just that far beyond people talent wise.

Floyd never had close fights? Castillio and Dela Hoya to name a couple

[JaNnO]

Your a ****en nut hugger. PAC clearly hit JMM when he was down so call it even. He was lucky not to get Disqualified or a point taken away.

hold your horses...a'hoe. i'm no nut hugger like the others here. i call it as i see it. blame the ref and not pac. jmm low blowed at least 4 times last night and he should have deducted 1 point too.

[MikeBrew328]

Mayweather is #1 decisively, just like he wins his fights. Pacquaio is much more beatable. If JMM only lost by a point last night does that make him #2/3?? No

[squealpiggy]

Resume does mean something because you have to prove you're the best against the best.

It means something sure, but it doesn't mean everything. P4P is hypothetical and is all about who would win in a fight between. Resume is an indicator and nothing more. It would be hard to peg someone on the p4p lists if they haven't fought anyone.

[macman]

With Mayweather you have a situation where the #1 P4P fighter has become basically irrelevant to the sport.
(& I agree that he is still the #1 P4P fighter)

He's supposed to be the best Welterweight in the world, yet hasn't fought a real Welterweight in something like 2 years, inspite of their being plenty of good matches their for him.

The obvious is Cotto, & has been for a while, but Mosley would be interesting as well.
The winner of Margarito-Cintron 2 would be another obvious candidate, but their are good serious contenders which would be very interesting to see how the fight plays out & would get him respect with solid victories
- Clottey, Quintana, Williams, Collazo...


Paquiao may not have the technical skills that Mayweather has, but he does what a top P4P fighter is supposed to be doing - fighting the best fighters out there in his weight class.


If Mayweather doesn't fight a real challenge at Welter in the next year, & Calzaghe beats Hopkins, will have him at #1 & Paquiao at #2 if he moves up & beats Diaz as expected.

[salinass1234]

hold your horses...a'hoe. i'm no nut hugger like the others here. i call it as i see it. blame the ref and not pac. jmm low blowed at least 4 times last night and he should have deducted 1 point too.

Man you have PAC so far up your ass that you were blinded by your squinting.
If your gonna say blame the ref the take your own advice. JMM is clearly superior to him in all aspects of Boxing and you know this. IF your not a nut hugger just admit it.

[Parody]

26% Agree with you