Has Pacquiao surpassed Mayweather as the #1 P4P fighter

[WLAD OWNS]

I think Pacman is the #1 p4p fighter now...His resume and opposition is more impressive than Mayweather's.

[Point Blank]

to me he does. why? he fought the top fighters in his divisions and knocked them down while floyd ducks top fighters in his weight class

[GodOfWar]

I will put him up there if he goes up in weight and fights Michael Katsidis. Probably a tie with mayweather if he takes that fight

[D_Chosen_1]

I will put him up there if he goes up in weight and fights Michael Katsidis. Probably a tie with mayweather if he takes that fight

Katsidis is going to get schooled like a school girl by Casamayor so your point is moot.

[sunny31]

not in a million years!!!!!! Manny was outboxed and out thought for the majority of tonight, and im a ricky hatton fan, mayweather has barely been outboxed or out thought for a single round in his career

[loui_ludwig]

Hell no. Pac is still #2.

[raysan]

I think Pacman is the #1 p4p fighter now...His resume and opposition is more impressive than Mayweather's.

How, if its clear hes not as good as Floyd, and many people and sports writers had him losing to Marquez not once but twice now. Floyd is so good he isnt even given close fights, thats not his fault, hes just that far beyond people talent wise.

[wmute]

to me he does. why? he fought the top fighters in his divisions and knocked them down while floyd ducks top fighters in his weight class

old featherweights are top fighters at 130?

[UnderPressure]

He had his chance in the 3rd round...

But number 2 is secured for him.

[Tyson Jones]

I like pac more than mayweather. But Mayweather is p4p number 1 until he loses. Pac is definently 2, If calzaghe finds a way to knock out bhop ( which I doubt ) then he'll be 2 and pac will be 3. But I have it like this currently and if calzaghe wins the expected 12 round ud against bho.

Floyd
Pac
Cal