Is Floyd Mayweather an All-Time Great?

[C'MONMANG']

Why shouldn't I? Am I lying when I said he quit?

regardless if he quit or lost or farted. HE STILL BEAT CASAMAYOR WHO YOU SAID WOULD BE A DECENT NAME. So FRIETAS should be one too. He wasnt a journey man, one punch wonder who caught Casa on a bad night. he simply beat him.

[Hagler★]

No, he needs Cotto and I think he will find that out soon.

why is every1 goin on like cotto is the boogyman that can final take mayweather's undefeated record. His defence is poor and a boxer like Mayweather would pick him apart and despite the fact cotto has superior punching power will cotto actually ever catch him in the fight

[flat1985]

To all the ****** Fake FLoyd fans. Here's something to ponder on. Hope your brains is capable of discerning this.

Question no. 1

Do you consider an ATG a guy who's best fight was against a blown-up 140 guy?

It's kinda funny when a little logic quashes ******ity eh?

Question no. 2

Do you consider someone as ATG when his resume lacks names like these.

Freitas, Casamayor, KOstya, Margarito, Cotto, WIlliams, Cintron.

Those 2 questions are answerable by PLAIN AND BASIC COMMON SENSE.

We don't need a rocker scientist to know the answer.

Why does he have to beat them to be an ATG?

[tredh]

regardless if he quit or lost or farted. HE STILL BEAT CASAMAYOR WHO YOU SAID WOULD BE A DECENT NAME. So FRIETAS should be one too. He wasnt a journey man, one punch wonder who caught Casa on a bad night. he simply beat him.

Freitas was overrated and didn't do **** really. Freitas fell off quickly like a bad bag of dope.

[Sweet Pete]

Why does he have to beat them to be an ATG?

Well, the fact that I don't see him as capable of beating Williams for one. Cotto and Williams are by far his biggest tests.

[C'MONMANG']

Freitas was overrated and didn't do **** really. Freitas fell off quickly like a bad bag of dope.

hmm, Judah, he fell off BEFORE Floyd fought him..

Baldo, was he as overrated as freitas?

Gatti? he wasnt overrrated, man after Dela beat him down and Ward beat him lol, you can justify that but not a fight with Freitas?

Chop Chop? Judah just spanked him then Floyd picked up the left overs, here from him latley??

man, you can knock guys that Floyd NEVER fought but look at the ones he did LOL.. you suck bro

[pbftxrs316]

floyd is an all time great no doubt. talent wise, resume wise, overall, he is a all time great, i just don't know where to rank him yet, because his career isn't officially over yet, but as for right now, it's no doubt, he's an all time great, and he is def in the top 30 so far, he will get higher once his career is over.

[flat1985]

Well, the fact that I don't see him as capable of beating Williams for one. Cotto and Williams are by far his biggest tests.

I think Williams is overated until i see more from him

[-Swizzy-]

a blown up 140 ha. what is mayweather than, a blown up 130? hatton walks around at 180 so 147 isn't anything. and his greatest victory is over DLH which is a great victory. and before you argue that DLH is too old let me shut you: He beat mayorga<---who beat Vernon Forrest twice<---who beat mosley twice. So needless to say, DLH was tip-top in that fight.

Mayweathers punch stat numbers destroy every punch stat number of any fighter EVER!

He fought Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, DLH, Judah and beat them handely. If he didn't fight those guys you would be here printing their names and saying how they could beat him and how he is ducking them cuz he is scared. SAD.

what, no reply to that JoartCC? I thought so.

[tredh]

hmm, Judah, he fell off BEFORE Floyd fought him..

Baldo, was he as overrated as freitas?

Gatti? he wasnt overrrated, man after Dela beat him down and Ward beat him lol, you can justify that but not a fight with Freitas?

Chop Chop? Judah just spanked him then Floyd picked up the left overs, here from him latley??

man, you can knock guys that Floyd NEVER fought but look at the ones he did LOL.. you suck bro

You won't find a post on here from claiming those guys as great or world beaters so don't ASSume **** about what I think of those fighters. Actually Freitas is on those guys levels so like I said no need to fight him when it would have just been more of the same.

I don't suck your mom and wife/woman does that to me.