Is Floyd Mayweather an All-Time Great?

[C'MONMANG']

If you really think the PBF's best was against a blown up 140 guy you and you're hate for PBF is sad especially if you are supposed to be a grown man.

To make it worse the only legit names on the list for your second question is Tyszu and Cotto. The reality of things it takes two fighters to make a fight so one side can never take all the blame. Casamayor would have been a respectable name. Freitas the quitter yes that does a lot for a guys resume. Margarito yeah ****ing right. Williams too young right now so his name can be bypassed for the time being. Cintron the crybaby who lost to Margarito says it all for him right now.
Your hate and bias is ****ing disgusting. I will not and can not condone all of PBF's career choices but the **** you talking doesn't even make sense.

errrr...
Frietas beat Casa so um, then he would have been a respectable name too right?

Spadafora maybe? Floyd fought SOSA who Spaddy already beat, even though Spaddy was calling Floyd out..

you are discrediting guys, but the guys he did fight in some cases are less credible.


your love is border line obsessive

[Boxinguru]

He has the potential to be one of the best ever! I would call him one based off his skill set alone, but we know it's more to the story than just skills/talents! Winning 5 titles in 5 different weight classes will def. make him a first ballot hall of famer! Right now he is still active & lacks a few marquee names to be considered an "ALL-TIME GREAT"... If he gives Cotto a chance and beats him you can make a strong argument! If he unifies the WW titles their will be no doubt!

He's a GREAT fighter...but right now you can't put him in the same league as a Sugar Ray (both), Ali, Foreman, & etc as far as opposition... so as of right now unfourtnately NO he isn't and this is coming from one his biggest fans/admirers! (not fan-boy or nut-hugger)... Just calling it how i see it!

[niceguy45]

he is half way........

[big paulie]

Only time will tell, right now floyd is p4p 1 and undefeated with wins over some very good fighters, he has everything it takes to go down as a great

[Sweet Pete]

He is an all time great, yes. How high is the question. I have him just inside the top 40.

[BandWagon]

I think he has the potential to be ATG, but if he quits now, it will always be this kind of argument.

[J90]

..who?

[tredh]

errrr...
Frietas beat Casa so um, then he would have been a respectable name too right?

Spadafora maybe? Floyd fought SOSA who Spaddy already beat, even though Spaddy was calling Floyd out..

you are discrediting guys, but the guys he did fight in some cases are less credible.


your love is border line obsessive

I said nothing about Spadafora who I liked very much back then and wish he didn't **** up. Rahman beat Lennox Lewis so that logic isn't the best when talking about Freitas beating Casamayor.

Your hate for PBF has been past obsessive.

[C'MONMANG']

I said nothing about Spadafora who I liked very much back then and wish he didn't **** up. Rahman beat Lennox Lewis so that logic isn't the best when talking about Freitas beating Casamayor.

Your hate for PBF has been past obsessive.

please dude, stop reaching.. you are knocking Freitas but he beat Casa , now you are bringing up Rahman/Lewis

[tredh]

please dude, stop reaching.. you are knocking Freitas but he beat Casa , now you are bringing up Rahman/Lewis

Why shouldn't I? Am I lying when I said he quit?