Is Floyd Mayweather an All-Time Great?

[Scott9945]

"All time great" is such a vague term. I'd have to see a list of other supposed ATG's to make it relevant. But since he'll almost surely be a first ballot hall of famer I'd say yes he is.

[tredh]

To all the ****** Fake FLoyd fans. Here's something to ponder on. Hope your brains is capable of discerning this.

Question no. 1

Do you consider an ATG a guy who's best fight was against a blown-up 140 guy?

It's kinda funny when a little logic quashes ******ity eh?

Question no. 2

Do you consider someone as ATG when his resume lacks names like these.

Freitas, Casamayor, KOstya, Margarito, Cotto, WIlliams, Cintron.

Those 2 questions are answerable by PLAIN AND BASIC COMMON SENSE.

We don't need a rocker scientist to know the answer.

If you really think the PBF's best was against a blown up 140 guy you and you're hate for PBF is sad especially if you are supposed to be a grown man.

To make it worse the only legit names on the list for your second question is Tyszu and Cotto. The reality of things it takes two fighters to make a fight so one side can never take all the blame. Casamayor would have been a respectable name. Freitas the quitter yes that does a lot for a guys resume. Margarito yeah ****ing right. Williams too young right now so his name can be bypassed for the time being. Cintron the crybaby who lost to Margarito says it all for him right now.
Your hate and bias is ****ing disgusting. I will not and can not condone all of PBF's career choices but the **** you talking doesn't even make sense.

[Tijuana Tornado]

To all the ****** Fake FLoyd fans. Here's something to ponder on. Hope your brains is capable of discerning this.

Question no. 1

Do you consider an ATG a guy who's best fight was against a blown-up 140 guy?

It's kinda funny when a little logic quashes ******ity eh?

Question no. 2

Do you consider someone as ATG when his resume lacks names like these.

Freitas, Casamayor, KOstya, Margarito, Cotto, WIlliams, Cintron.

Those 2 questions are answerable by PLAIN AND BASIC COMMON SENSE.

We don't need a rocker scientist to know the answer.

It's unfortunate that Mayweather's fans are just not capable of using even the most plain and the most basic common sense.

[JoartCC]

If you really think the PBF's best was against a blown up 140 guy you and you're hate for PBF is sad especially if you are supposed to be a grown man.

To make it worse the only legit names on the list for your second question is Tyszu and Cotto. The reality of things it takes two fighters to make a fight so one side can never take all the blame. Casamayor would have been a respectable name. Freitas the quitter yes that does a lot for a guys resume. Margarito yeah ****ing right. Williams too young right now so his name can be bypassed for the time being. Cintron the crybaby who lost to Margarito says it all for him right now.
Your hate and bias is ****ing disgusting. I will not and can not condone all of PBF's career choices but the **** you talking doesn't even make sense.

OK ok. You replied.

But let's make it an orderly argument.

I have 2 questions.

Please follow the format and answer the question in ordely fashion so that I can reply in the same manner.

I realized idiots and ******ity can never be cured by the same idiocy and ******ity applied to them. Afterall man is a thinking creature and it is my fervent hope that after presenting PLAIN AND BASIC COMMON SENSE points that MAYBE just MAYBE they'll begin to use their proper faculties.

So please good sir please answer my questions in a per-order manner so I could reply to you in kind.

[tredh]

It's unfortunate that Mayweather's fans are just not capable of using even the most plain and the most basic common sense.

You have a lot of ****ing nerve to talk about a person using plain and the most basic common sense when you believe Margarito is a elite level fighter.

[JoartCC]

It's unfortunate that Mayweather's fans are just not capable of using even the most plain and the most basic common sense.

I will try to present to them valid points and if after presentation they still prefer idiocy then it's up to them.

[*!#@PBRick@#!*]

I will try to present to them valid points and if after presentation they still prefer idiocy then it's up to them.

You are by far the dumbest smart person on this forum... You can not deny Floyd talent or his skill level yet, you try to find a flaw in opponents... You can not say anything about his 39-0 record so you talk about guys he hasn't fought to try to overshadow the fact he has never been beat...

Floyd hater's are comical... Can we just agree he is one of the most skilled and technically sound boxers of all time?

ESPN did something on boxing's ATG and determined it by in-ring performance, achievements, dominance, and mainstream appeal... Where is Floyd lacking in these areas?

[The Hammer]

Tijuana, you have accurately evaluated Mayweather's resume. Your opening post in this thread is one of the best I've ever seen in a boxing forum. Here's a five star rating!

[tredh]

OK ok. You replied.

But let's make it an orderly argument.

I have 2 questions.

Please follow the format and answer the question in ordely fashion so that I can reply in the same manner.

I realized idiots and ******ity can never be cured by the same idiocy and ******ity applied to them. Afterall man is a thinking creature and it is my fervent hope that after presenting PLAIN AND BASIC COMMON SENSE points that MAYBE just MAYBE they'll begin to use their proper faculties.

So please good sir please answer my questions in a per-order manner so I could reply to you in kind.

I answered your questions in order. I then just took the names on your list after I answered your second question and broke them down out of order.

[-Swizzy-]

To all the ****** Fake FLoyd fans. Here's something to ponder on. Hope your brains is capable of discerning this.

Question no. 1

Do you consider an ATG a guy who's best fight was against a blown-up 140 guy?

It's kinda funny when a little logic quashes ******ity eh?

Question no. 2

Do you consider someone as ATG when his resume lacks names like these.

Freitas, Casamayor, KOstya, Margarito, Cotto, WIlliams, Cintron.

Those 2 questions are answerable by PLAIN AND BASIC COMMON SENSE.

We don't need a rocker scientist to know the answer.

a blown up 140 ha. what is mayweather than, a blown up 130? hatton walks around at 180 so 147 isn't anything. and his greatest victory is over DLH which is a great victory. and before you argue that DLH is too old let me shut you: He beat mayorga<---who beat Vernon Forrest twice<---who beat mosley twice. So needless to say, DLH was tip-top in that fight.

Mayweathers punch stat numbers destroy every punch stat number of any fighter EVER!

He fought Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, DLH, Judah and beat them handely. If he didn't fight those guys you would be here printing their names and saying how they could beat him and how he is ducking them cuz he is scared. SAD.