Who is the True #1 P4P fighter in Boxing?

[wmute]

Great he is fighting the man at 140. Floyd doesnt fight at 140.

1) Floyd comes in at 147 on fight night.

2) Did anyone knock on Sweet Pea for fighting JCC (just like now, 147 vs 140 ring champion)? I dont think so...

PW, Cotto and Mosley would all beat HAtton and probably a few other welters like MArgo and Clottey and Cintron COLLAZO.

Hmmm Hatton W12 Collazo

Thanks for your opinions on possible matchups at 147, how are they useful to the conversation?

BTW I pick Cotto to beat Hatton and Mayweather to beat Cotto, but I
am not sure at all about Mayweather beating Hatton. In my book Mayweather picked the hardest fight FOR HIM.

Funny with all the great match ups Floyd is the least anticipated. Cus he should be fighting a top welter.. Fans are ******. Cotto Mosley, will be better..pAVLIK/tAYLOR better, Calzaghe/ Kessler BETTER..cuz they makes sense. Top guys in same division fighting eachother..

least anticipated?

sold out in 30 minutes? two undefeated ring champions? Press conference all over he world with people attending them under the rain?

if you call this least anticipated... idk what to say.

In all of this Cotto-Mosley's tickets are still being sold...

are you dumb or what?

Finally, as a sidenote, Hatton and Mayweather will weight the same by fight night.

[eazy_mas]

Great he is fighting the man at 140. Floyd doesnt fight at 140.

PW, Cotto and Mosley would all beat HAtton and probably a few other welters like MArgo and Clottey and Cintron COLLAZO.

Funny with all the great match ups Floyd's is the least anticipated. Cus he should be fighting a top welter.. Fans arent ******. Cotto Mosley, will be better..pAVLIK/tAYLOR better, Calzaghe/ Kessler BETTER..cuz they makes sense. Top guys in same division fighting eachother..

well then what weight Floyd started? it funny how you talk Hatton is taking stepping to WW when he was jr WW when Floyd was 130 went all the way to 154

[wmute]

I have to go now.

Let me remind you again that Mayweather cleaned a division when he was 10 years younger than Calzaghe was, after that he moved up collecting lineal championships and belts.

These are some of the very simple reasons for which at this point 60 people voted Mayweather #1 and only 23 voted Calzaghe #1.

I ll be back on monday, let me know if you understand them.

[C'MONMANG']

well then what weight Floyd started? it funny how you talk Hatton is taking stepping to WW when he was jr WW when Floyd was 130 went all the way to 154

Bottom line is Floyd has stated TWICE that he wont fight the number 1 guy in his division. iF your okay with that as a boxing fan so be it.

[C'MONMANG']

1) Floyd comes in at 147 on fight night.

2) Did anyone knock on Sweet Pea for fighting JCC (just like now, 147 vs 140 ring champion)? I dont think so...



Hmmm Hatton W12 Collazo

Thanks for your opinions on possible matchups at 147, how are they useful to the conversation?

BTW I pick Cotto to beat Hatton and Mayweather to beat Cotto, but I
am not sure at all about Mayweather beating Hatton. In my book Mayweather picked the hardest fight FOR HIM.



least anticipated?

sold out in 30 minutes? two undefeated ring champions? Press conference all over he world with people attending them under the rain?
if you call this least anticipated... idk what to say.

In all of this Cotto-Mosley's tickets are still being sold...

are you dumb or what?

Finally, as a sidenote, Hatton and Mayweather will weight the same by fight night.

thanks to the Brits

Cotto/Mosley added tickets and STILL selling there is a diff.

side not. you dont know what ANYONE will weigh UNTIL fight night.

[PeROxiDE]

Let's see him be lineal champion at lightheavy and cruiser, then we can talk about p4p.

P4P means IF THEY WERE THE SAME WEIGHT. Moving up through the divisions and winning more titles, although impressive, means nothing in P4P rankings by the very definition.

[eazy_mas]

Bottom line is Floyd has stated TWICE that he wont fight the number 1 guy in his division. iF your okay with that as a boxing fan so be it.

well he rates them as the WBC rates there fighters

at 147 when floyd was figting Zab people said he should be figting Baldomir and when he did they said he should be fighting Margarito and when he fought DHL , then there is a review of Castillo-Mayweather 1, it robbery blah blah blah.

if Floyd fights Margarito then people will say he should be fighting Williams because Margarito got beaten by him or fight Hatton. Every time he fight someone people are talking about the other person Floyd is fighting.

fighter only fight couple time a year, and you rarely seeing a fighter fight everybody they calls out his name.

[Jim Jeffries]

I have to go now.

Let me remind you again that Mayweather cleaned a division when he was 10 years younger than Calzaghe was, after that he moved up collecting lineal championships and belts.

These are some of the very simple reasons for which at this point 60 people voted Mayweather #1 and only 23 voted Calzaghe #1.

I ll be back on monday, let me know if you understand them.

Explain to me how Mayweather "cleaned out" ANY division without unifying the belts?

[Technical_Skill]

Explain to me how Mayweather "cleaned out" ANY division without unifying the belts?

**** unifying the belts, he was the Champion at 130,135,147 technically winky was the man at 154, but he moved up and so floyd became the man after beating de la hoya no? (might be wrong on that one)

**** calzaghe's 20+ defences, about 16-17 of those guys were nobodies, why dont you post the names up and see for yourself.

[Jim Jeffries]

**** unifying the belts, he was the Champion at 130,135,147 technically winky was the man at 154, but he moved up and so floyd became the man after beating de la hoya no? (might be wrong on that one)

**** calzaghe's 20+ defences, about 16-17 of those guys were nobodies, why dont you post the names up and see for yourself.

Yeah you're right, Floyd cleaned out 154 too.