Who is the True #1 P4P fighter in Boxing?

[Burning Desire]

I think people are getting a bit too excited with Calzaghe and Kessler fight lets just compare there career shall we ??

Floyd Mayweather best wins

Diego Corrales
Oscar De La Hoya
Jose Luis Castillo
Arturo Gatti
Angel Manfredy
Jesus Chavez
Zab Judah
Carlos Baldomir

World titles in 5 different weight classes.


Joe Calzaghe's best wins.

Mikkel Kessler
Jeff Lacy
Robin Reid
Chris Eubank
Richie Woodhall
Mario Veit
Charles Brewer
Byron Mitchell

Unified 168 World champion.

Sorry i like Calzaghe but no way should he be P4P number 1.

[squealpiggy]

The fighter who is more skilled, fought better fighters throughout his career, and dominated much bigger fighters than himself.

Manny Pacquiao?

[markosg]

Mayweather is the best fighter in the world............... that is a given. The fact hat he can fight 3 weights above his natural weight and still beat Delahoya solidifies that. I would put Joe at second behind him as i think he is far more skilled than Paquiao.

[Technical_Skill]

Manny Pacquiao?

And who is manny pacquaio more Skilled than?

Mayweather?

or Calzaghe

Or Rafeal Marquez

Or Neither?

[F.O.S]

Sorry i like Calzaghe but no way should he be P4P number 1.

And if Mayweather loses to Hatton Dec 8th, would you still have Mayweather ahead of Calzaghe ?

[Technical_Skill]

And if Mayweather loses to Hatton Dec 8th, would you still have Mayweather ahead of Calzaghe ?

Yes because he lost to a p4p fighter.

Name me 1 p4p fighter joe calzaghe fought in his entire career, any one fighter thats ever been on the p4p list that calzaghe has fought.

[me2007]

p4p is a mythical list created by americans. Non americans have to be twice as good to get on it.

P4P is bull****.

If Mayweather loses, he is a nobody.

[Mozza]

Yes because he lost to a p4p fighter.

Name me 1 p4p fighter joe calzaghe fought in his entire career, any one fighter thats ever been on the p4p list that calzaghe has fought.

When was the last time Mayweather fought a P4P fighter?

[Technical_Skill]

When was the last time Mayweather fought a P4P fighter?

De la Hoya was on the p4p list many a time.

He is fighting Hatton who is currently on the list right now.

Name me the fighter that at one stage or another, has been on the p4p list at some stage, that calzaghe has fought.

[eazy_mas]

I love casamayor as a fighter, personally, i think he is better than calzaghe skills wise too, and yet no one talks about him,

Bu i also heard that casamayor didnt wanna mess with floyd, personally, i have floyd winning that fight.

But casamayor is a such a skilled fighter.

I think Casamayor will win if they fought that time but know Mayweather is more matured as a fighter and he is good in dealing with southpaw

And if Mayweather loses to Hatton Dec 8th, would you still have Mayweather ahead of Calzaghe ?

ofcourse not Calzaghe will be the p4p champion if Mayweather lost to Hatton.