Who has the better legacy, Pacquiao or Mayweather?

[sonofisis]

Paquiao gave us entertaining and convincing wins such as fights against Morales and MAB. While the other guy, Floyd gave us boring, questionable and unsatisfactory fights against Castillo and Dela Hoya. He would be better entertaining us in NFL playing as running back, wat da ya tink?

I'm tired of you robots continuously talking about "exciting" this and that and then bring up the same two old as Mexican fighters when defending Pacquiao. This seriously lets me know that Pacquiao is waaaaaay overrated since his fans rely on the ad nauseum fallacy of repeating the same nonsense over and over again, parroting what others say and trying to pass it off as legitimate.

He is really fast, but extremely one dimensional. Pac throws his right hand like his left is broke and lunges in like an amateur. He's exciting because he lacks skill! Sometimes I think some of you weirdos should stop watching boxing and go to UFC, because you people are definitely not boxing fans, and I promise you that. All you want is blood n guts, that is not boxing and I don't care what anyone says. That is bar room brawling. Right hand after right hand is not boxing, with an occasional straight left is not boxing, it is wreckless.. Take that **** to UFC, Pac is a one punch pony who beat two old ass mexicans, there's no way around that ****, his legacy is trash compared to Floyd's at 130 alone.

Pac only beat two people, get over it!

[Bogler]

I'm tired of you robots continuously talking about "exciting" this and that and then bring up the same two old as Mexican fighters when defending Pacquiao. This seriously lets me know that Pacquiao is waaaaaay overrated since his fans rely on the ad nauseum fallacy of repeating the same nonsense over and over again, parroting what others say and trying to pass it off as legitimate.

He is really fast, but extremely one dimensional. Pac throws his right hand like his left is broke and lunges in like an amateur. He's exciting because he lacks skill! Sometimes I think some of you weirdos should stop watching boxing and go to UFC, because you people are definitely not boxing fans, and I promise you that. All you want is blood n guts, that is not boxing and I don't care what anyone says. That is bar room brawling. Right hand after right hand is not boxing, with an occasional straight left is not boxing, it is wreckless.. Take that **** to UFC, Pac is a one punch pony who beat two old ass mexicans, there's no way around that ****, his legacy is trash compared to Floyd's at 130 alone.

Pac only beat two people, get over it!

then you do not know your boxing. manny defeated champs throughout his career from 108 to 130, you only remember mab and em i guess?

[boxingfan4life]

I would have to say mayweather. Hes won more championshipas and IMO fought more quality opponents than pac man.

[AIR_KENG]

list the top 5 most memorable fights of both fighters... even make it top ten and compare them. and think like 10-15 years from now, whose fights would be talked about more? i think that pretty much answers your question.

[El Jesus]

list the top 5 most memorable fights of both fighters... even make it top ten and compare them. and think like 10-15 years from now, whose fights would be talked about more? i think that pretty much answers your question.

no it doesnt, thats like saying gatti is a superior fighter to pernell whitaker and will also have a better legacy than winky wright. That doesnt mean anything at all.

[tredh]

then you do not know your boxing. manny defeated champs throughout his career from 108 to 130, you only remember mab and em i guess?

As far as the bold goes the same can be said of people always claiming PBF is a runner. Before the Baldomir fight nobody ever said that ****. People here need to stop acting like PBF's record is 2-0 instead of 38-0. The same can be said of Manny he has fought other people besides MAB and Morales. You can't include Marquez in Pac's wins because the fight was a draw. If people would look at both fighters records as a whole instead of this what have you done lately **** its no way you can say Manny's resume and legacy is better than PBF. That is not to say in the end when it is all said and done that Manny's resume and legacy couldn't be better than PBF's because it very well could but as of right now it is not.

[tredh]

Paquiao gave us entertaining and convincing wins such as fights against Morales and MAB. While the other guy, Floyd gave us boring, questionable and unsatisfactory fights against Castillo and Dela Hoya. He would be better entertaining us in NFL playing as running back, wat da ya tink?

Nothing was in doubt about that De la Hoya fight that is bull****. Only thing about that fight which could be questioned(which I don't personally agree with) is margin of the scores but PBF clearly won that fight. What was questionable about the rematch between PBF and Castillo? It is so convient for you PBF haters to leave out the rematch. That **** is sad. Just for the sake of arguement and to be biased like so many of you here.
AT LEAST PBF GAVE CASTILLO A IMMEDIATE REMATCH MANNY DIDN'T GIVE MARQUEZ A IMMEDIATE REMATCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[AIR_KENG]

no it doesnt, thats like saying gatti is a superior fighter to pernell whitaker and will also have a better legacy than winky wright. That doesnt mean anything at all.

well it does in a way... legacy is something that people remember you for... so really it is quite not appropriate to plainly compare the legacies of people... floyd with his skill and defense will always be compared to a pernell whittaker... pac will be compared to someone in terms of excitement and volume punching or power punching, whatever suits the inquirer...

seriously they will leave different legacies and it will be incomparable.

[Bogler]

Nothing was in doubt about that De la Hoya fight that is bull****. Only thing about that fight which could be questioned(which I don't personally agree with) is margin of the scores but PBF clearly won that fight. What was questionable about the rematch between PBF and Castillo? It is so convient for you PBF haters to leave out the rematch. That **** is sad. Just for the sake of arguement and to be biased like so many of you here.
AT LEAST PBF GAVE CASTILLO A IMMEDIATE REMATCH MANNY DIDN'T GIVE MARQUEZ A IMMEDIATE REMATCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

uh-oh you dont know your history. you're gonna burn yourself w/ those bolded caps statement of yours...

[sonofisis]

uh-oh you dont know your history. .

Obviously YOU don't know anything if this is your only response, that you depend on every single time it seems. This is appealing to ad hominem and won't help you or Pac's legacy and only makes you look foolish and childish. Learn how to rebut point for point..