Who has the better legacy, Pacquiao or Mayweather?

[ßringer]

lol i wonder what he would say if he was talking **** to manny

****, lord knows he has enough material already. He could attack his acting career, his singing career, his run for Congress, the rumors about his ******** addiction, etc.... I'd pay good money to see those two guys fight, and even better money just to see the press conferences.

[joepal]

The sane people don't leave out Floyd's biggest accomplishments and underrate a guy like Hernandez or Corley. Corley was always a B level fighter with the power to test even the toughest of Champions, after Floyd beat him he went on to nearly KO Miguel Cotto. Not to mention a prime Corrales, a prime Castillo and a still very dangerous Oscar De La Hoya. (Dangerous as in he knows how to steal a round, not like he can KO you.)

So who are Floyd's best wins? Corrales, Castillo and DLH? Pac fought MAB twice (Castillo beat Floyd, and please, MAB is SO much a greater fighter than JLC), Morales thrice (I like Chico but he just aint near the skill-level of a Morales) and JMM whom Pac beat if not for a scoring error (DLH is SOOOOO not the DLH before, and has lost to lots before the Floyd fight).

There just is no frigging comparison. Pac by a mile in terms of resume. And I'm not even going to the other indicators of greatness like excitement, etc.

[heder]

That's odd, considering that Floyd's resume at 130 and 135 is better than Pac's whole career..

who has floyd fought at 130 135? if you're gonna say something like that you could atleast drop some names, or can't you?

[joepal]

Mayweather has money out the ass... pacman has to go to law school to make money...

Who the fugg knows about Mayweather? I got relatives in NY and they havent even heard of any Mayweather in their whole life. Pac on the other hand has 500 MILLION FANS all over the world.

STFU.

[ßringer]

So who are Floyd's best wins? Corrales, Castillo and DLH? Pac fought MAB twice (Castillo beat Floyd, and please, MAB is SO much a greater fighter than JLC), Morales thrice (I like Chico but he just aint near the skill-level of a Morales) and JMM whom Pac beat if not for a scoring error (DLH is SOOOOO not the DLH before, and has lost to lots before the Floyd fight).

There just is no frigging comparison. Pac by a mile in terms of resume. And I'm not even going to the other indicators of greatness like excitement, etc.

You will not hear me disagree that Barrera is a greater win than Castillo. But that also doesn't discredit Castillo at all, he was still one of the best of his generation. Mayweather took on Corrales at a time when Corrales was undefeated and nobody wanted anything to do with him, and he embarassed him and made it look easy.

Morales and Barrera both were past their primes when Pac beat them, the same as Oscar was past him when Mayweather beat him. Overall I think Mayweathers record coupled with being an undefeated Champion in 5 different weightclasses is better than Pacquiao's record against 2 old legends.

[heder]

Genaro Hernandez had NEVER lost at 130 and it was only his 17th or 18th pro fight, fighting for a legit title.

I don't think Angel Manfredy and Carlos Hernandez were all that. Genaro was good though.

genaro was dismantled by dlh, then floyd fought him

[ReadyUp]

Who the fugg knows about Mayweather? I got relatives in NY and they havent even heard of any Mayweather in their whole life. Pac on the other hand has 500 MILLION FANS all over the world.

STFU.

And if Pacquaio wasn't filipino then your relatives wouldn't have heard about him either.....bigggg deallllllll.

[joepal]

I'm sick of Pac fans saying Pac would eat Mayweather for breakfast. If Pac really wants Mayweather why not just move up to Welterweight? He weighed in at 144lbs on Saturday, Welterweight is just 3lbs north of that. Maybe he should challenge Mayweather out in the open, and see what happens.

I can see it now, Mayweather talking about how many more Filippino fans he has than Pacquiao, like he said British fans against Hatton. That would be hilarious, but Mayweather would still take every round from Pac.

If you're sick of PacFans saying Pac beats Mayweather, shouldnt you be FURIOUS at Floyd fan's saying he's the greatest? Or Floyd himself saying he was the greatest? I cant believe you'd hate on Pac who he himself said that he was just a good fighter.

So you want a guy who started at 108 to fight a guy who started at 130. Bring it on man. Pac would love to fight Floyd at 140. Hell, he'd fight Hatton at 140 IN MACHESTER. Your man Floyd on the other hand never had the cojones to do that.

[joepal]

And if Pacquaio wasn't filipino then your relatives wouldn't have heard about him either.....bigggg deallllllll.

Hell no! Even the CHINESE love Pacquaio, they got a shrine to him in Shanghai!

[ßringer]

If you're sick of PacFans saying Pac beats Mayweather, shouldnt you be FURIOUS at Floyd fan's saying he's the greatest? Or Floyd himself saying he was the greatest? I cant believe you'd hate on Pac who he himself said that he was just a good fighter.

So you want a guy who started at 108 to fight a guy who started at 130. Bring it on man. Pac would love to fight Floyd at 140. Hell, he'd fight Hatton at 140 IN MACHESTER. Your man Floyd on the other hand never had the cojones to do that.

Floyd's not my man! Do a search for a thread called "Attention Mayweather fans" by me and you'll see that clearly. I'm sick of both fighters' and their fans running around screaming about who's better. That said, I've also been watching this sport almost my entire life and realize that Mayweather would school Pacquiao easily. That doesn't make me a nuthugger of Mayweather, nor does it make me a Pacquiao hater. It makes me opinionated.