Were Tszyu and Castillo Shot When Hatton Fought Them?

[wmute]

zoo was old and just camw off of surgery. hatton aint ****

Wrong, Zoo just came off a 3 rounds destruction of Mitchell.
Everyone rated him high on p4p list.
Everyone picked him to murder Hatton.
You are just hating.

[squealpiggy]

He beat Ngoudjo, even though he looked bad doing it. He could have raised his game to beat just about everyone else at 140 lbs with the possible exceptions of Malignaggi and maybe, maybe Witter.

[wmute]

He beat Ngoudjo, even though he looked bad doing it. He could have raised his game to beat just about everyone else at 140 lbs with the possible exceptions of Malignaggi and maybe, maybe Witter.

You are just giving your opinion again, the only empirical fact are the Ngoudjo and Hatton fights, which go against your hypothesis.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

both were shot, but had chances at beating hatton IMO, so i give him a little credit for beating them, i would favor prime castillo over hatton though....

Shot out of a cannon.

[$iN]

He beat Ngoudjo, even though he looked bad doing it. He could have raised his game to beat just about everyone else at 140 lbs with the possible exceptions of Malignaggi and maybe, maybe Witter.

That just goes to show how terrible 140 is at this time if you think a shot fighter could beat all of the other top fighters in the division...

[Lazy Liberal]

Tszyu was not shot, he destroyed Mitchell but his lack of activity cost him at the end. Castillo was not Yory Boy Campas but he did spend too much time trying to make weight at 135 instead of moving up. Castillo was a good solid champ at 135 but not elite. Hatton beating him was the result of a young lion taking out the old veteran who still had fight in him but could not go back in time.

[Eno]

I don't think Tszyu was shot but he was definately past his best. Castillo was shot though.

[kayjay]

Only Castillo
Hatton is no legend or anything, but neither was Castillo. Prime Castillo probably gets a big fat ass pwnage like 9 of 10 times. He lost to worse fighters thasn Ricky Hatton.

Regarding, KT, it's hard to say he's shot b/c you need EVIDENCE of that other than the fight in question. In Castillo's case, you had a 'warm-up' he almost lost. KT was still on top when he met Hatton

[FISTIC ART]

...................

This is the problem with the internet its like the headquarters for critizism..... im a huge mayweather fan...i think hatton is outmatched in this fight...but thats just my opinion and nothing else....however....all i ever hear is more critizism than praise for any boxer...hattons fans bash mayweather ...mayweather fans bash hatton.... i think hatton is overrated but thats the medias fault..not hattons ...hatton goes out does what he does and rides the wave.....mayweather i think has a better resume and to rides the wave....anyone whos even boxed recreational knows the dedication it takes to box...let alone reach a world level and compete....nothing is enough for people...if mayweather is always ducking somebody ...now he signs to fight hatton...ohhh why is he fighting hatton why not fight cotto...if he fights cotto ohhh why not fight paul williams...if he fights paul williams ohhhh why not fight jesus... than u have hatton...ohhhh tzou was shot... castillo was shot...fought to many bums.... but the build up is by the media not hatton..he just fights who his camp picks for him....and both guys win....every fight is not gonna be against a superstar.... not every fighter u see ur gonna like his style of boxing...but if they win with it give them some credit...ohhh hatton hugs too much...ohhh mayweather runs around all the time... i know we wont agree with everything and want to give negative feedback...but people do it way to often and i never see any praise or compliments for what these boxers accomplish...as for me...hatton good job...and mayweather good job as well............

[wmute]

Only Castillo
Hatton is no legend or anything, but neither was Castillo. Prime Castillo probably gets a big fat ass pwnage like 9 of 10 times. He lost to worse fighters thasn Ricky Hatton.

Regarding, KT, it's hard to say he's shot b/c you need EVIDENCE of that other than the fight in question. In Castillo's case, you had a 'warm-up' he almost lost. KT was still on top when he met Hatton

Which of Castillo losses did you see?