Should Pacquiao be ranked ahead of PBF in P4P ranks?

[loui_ludwig]

If u count their past fights 2006 and before, then u have Mayweather at 1 and Pac at 2.

But if u count only year 2006, then Pac at 1 and PBF at 2.

[Tysonisgod]

no, cos hes not a better fighter

[Juggernaut]

At the moment, the poll says YES.

But is it just a case of there being more Pac fans than PBF fans?

Seems to me that this question is only being asked because of Pac's win over Morales recently. But we all know now Morales was indeed a shot fighter. So the fight proved nothing.

Was this question asked after he beat Morales in their 2nd fight?

Pac is being credited for a win over a shot fighter, but PBF was critisized for a totally dominant win over Baldomir. Too me there is little difference between both fights.

If Morales have beaten Pac in the 3rd fight, would people consider Morales shot anyways?

To reply to your last sentence, there is a big difference...PBF/Baldomir went the distance while Pac/Morales took 3 rounds.

But I still have PBF as #1 for the mere fact that he's still undefeated. P4P = opinions.

[Liaison]

I don’t know. He beat Morales twice, but in reality Erik has been a shot fighter for over 6 years now (this really says a lot about their first fight, was Pac bad or did Erik manage to capture some of his glory days form). At the moment I’ll say yes he’s above the pretty one as PBF hasn’t fought anyone valid in years (true Zab is technically almost as good as Floyd, but he doesn’t have any heart and gasses pretty early in his fights) while Pac certainly has, but he’s one below King Winky…

1.Winky
2.Pac
3.Floyd

Oh and if p4p equates to just boxing skill, that welsh boy is No 2 behind Floyd, while Winky would be third and maybe Pac at 4….

1.Floyd
2.Joe
3.Winky
4.Pac

[-EX-]

Erik is a shot fighter, so no I wouldn't put Pacquiao ahead of Mayweather. Also as a overall fighter Mayweather is a better fighter. Floyd is outboxing guys with bad hands. Also Pacquiao hasn't moved up and grabbed titles like Floyd has. If Floyd retires I think Pacquiao can be #1.

[realheavyhands]

1. ronald wright
2. floyd and paquioao

[-EX-]

I don't see how Winky is at the top of people's lists. He did beat Mosley twice but he dominated Trinidad who is washed up. He drawed with Jermain Taylor, beat that amateur Soliman, and beat Quartey.

[-EX-]

He couldn't take Jermain's belts. Winky has stayed at 154-160. Floyd has gone far past his natural weight. 4 titles in 4 weightclasses. If your basing it off of talent and skill Floyd is still ahead.

[-EX-]

I think both Winky and Pacquiao should be ahead of Mayweather. Yes Mayweather has skills but Winky and Pacquiao have been taking on harder opposition and been successful.

The best competition Winky fought recently Taylor he drawed with. Pacquiao beat up shot Morales. Winky beat old ass Quartey and Soliman. How is that better competition.

[realheavyhands]

really he beat taylor. and when winky is in as good of shape as floyd ,he would weigh about 152, he isnt even in great shape at 160