Should Pacquiao be ranked ahead of PBF in P4P ranks?

[The Surgeon]

At the moment, the poll says YES.

But is it just a case of there being more Pac fans than PBF fans?

Seems to me that this question is only being asked because of Pac's win over Morales recently. But we all know now Morales was indeed a shot fighter. So the fight proved nothing.

Was this question asked after he beat Morales in their 2nd fight?

Pac is being credited for a win over a shot fighter, but PBF was critisized for a totally dominant win over Baldomir. Too me there is little difference between both fights.

Thats oh so true man!

[Guest]

Judah isnt overrated, and Gatti wasnt shot.

Both of those statements are subjective. You speak as if they're "facts". And I beg to differ in both cases.

[{BrownBomber}]

Actually, **** this, YES.

Pac has nowhere near the technical skill of Floyd, but who knows how good Floyd is when he's bashing up the likes of shot Gatti and Baldi? The guy hasn't been in a fight since about 2002.

In the meantime Pac's resume is racking up Amigos.

exactly.........

[TheBlackWallStreet]

Hell no beating 2 fighters who got DOMINATED in their last fights does not equal you being the #1 P4P fighter. grab all the belts at 130 and move up and beat some people at 135 and then you might have a case. Till then all you people voting yes is out your mind. he is still behind Winky imo.

1. Floyd
2. Winky
3. Pac

[Guest]

exactly.........

I talk sense don't I, Amigo?

[monkeyboy]

Floyd is the best fighter today.
He is not taking the best fights.

It's all very well Floyd BEING special. I want to actually see him DO something special. Lots of decent fighters from lower weights could tag and run from Baldomir thus running up a clean points victory. I want to see Floyd USE this extra level of class that he has.
Every recent fighter Floyd has beaten has been beaten comprehensively by someone else. Floyd has to display his greatness and he hasn't done that as he hasn't either been challenged or demolished anyone (besides Gatti who should never have been allowed in the same ring).
P4P is an honor and it must be earned.
Pacquiao is impressing me more right now.
1) Pac
2) Floyd
3) Winky
All of them are within one fight of being no.1 on the list but just like Calzhage's last performance, if it ain't shown, I can't see it.

[Jcsuper]

Floyd is the best fighter today.
He is not taking the best fights.

It's all very well Floyd BEING special. I want to actually see him DO something special. Lots of decent fighters from lower weights could tag and run from Baldomir thus running up a clean points victory. I want to see Floyd USE this extra level of class that he has.
Every recent fighter Floyd has beaten has been beaten comprehensively by someone else. Floyd has to display his greatness and he hasn't done that as he hasn't either been challenged or demolished anyone (besides Gatti who should never have been allowed in the same ring).
P4P is an honor and it must be earned.
Pacquiao is impressing me more right now.
1) Pac
2) Floyd
3) Winky
All of them are within one fight of being no.1 on the list but just like Calzhage's last performance, if it ain't shown, I can't see it.

Pac is behind Pbf, Winky and Kessler, and if you talk of skills, he's behind Toney too...

[Chups]

At the moment, the poll says YES.

But is it just a case of there being more Pac fans than PBF fans?

It's a combination of Pacfans and Floyd haters....which I think is equal in numbers.

[TeamPac88]

I think both Winky and Pacquiao should be ahead of Mayweather. Yes Mayweather has skills but Winky and Pacquiao have been taking on harder opposition and been successful.

[MetalVomit]

Pacquiao knocked Morales the **** out, after this, anyone think Pacquiao should he should be ranked higher than Floyd?