Which ATG doesn't have any controversial decision win(s)?

[Anthony342]

So the answer to this question would be Tyson and possibly Louis? Or were there other guys whose wins weren't controversial? Jones would be here if not for the controversy of the first Tarver fight and his last fight, which hopefully really will be his last.

[JAB5239]

Marciano,,foreman (if you consider him top 10 which I do) lewis to an extent( holyfield2 and mercer fights were close)

Marciano's first fight with LaStarza was controversial and so was Foreman's fight with Schultz.

[LacedUp]

So the answer to this question would be Tyson and possibly Louis? Or were there other guys whose wins weren't controversial? Jones would be here if not for the controversy of the first Tarver fight and his last fight, which hopefully really will be his last.

Joe Louis scored a very controversial win over Jersey Joe Walcott. Louis was knocked down a couple of times and was dominated throughout most of the fight, but still ended up winning a SD.

[SBleeder]

I consider Gilberto Roman to be an all-time great, and I've never seen a win of his that was controversial.

[Anthony342]

Marciano's first fight with LaStarza was controversial and so was Foreman's fight with Schultz.

Agreed. How about Lennox Lewis?

[Anthony342]

So how about Tyson and Roman as answers then?

[Cardinal Buck]

Has Juan Manuel Marquez been added yet?

[Scott9945]

Has Juan Manuel Marquez been added yet?

Some have disputed the Barrera win. Not me personally, but I think Lederman had Barrera ahead.

[Barn]

Gotta say, I disagree on all three counts.

As for my own answer to the thread, Marvin Hagler. Yeah, the Leonard fight has controversy surrounding it but Hagler didn't get the decision so that doesn't fall into this particular category of 'gift decision'.

Arguably Juan Roldan where Hagler seemed to be having difficulty with his rugged style until he thumbed the guy.

[Barn]

Good choice, but you only have to check out the thread on his fight with SRL to see the controversy.. Deluded, i know, but some people are still saying that Hagler should have won..