Which ATG doesn't have any controversial decision win(s)?

[LoadedWraps]

I was debating somebody earlier when he did the usual discrediting due to some 'gift decisions' some ATG's had so I told him that the vast majority of greats have atleast one fight that was very close and could have gone either way. So my question is which ATG's did not really have a single questionable points victory?

Oscar. Marciano. Charles. ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

[mickey malone]

I heard Marciano mighta got a pass on lastarza in their first fight. then I remember foreman getting a pass on either ellis or shulz but that was very near the end of the line for him. I was thinkin pernell whitaker but then theres the first mgirt fight so i'll go with marvin haggler on this one

Good choice, but you only have to check out the thread on his fight with SRL to see the controversy.. Deluded, i know, but some people are still saying that Hagler should have won..

[Scott9945]

Oscar. Marciano. Charles. ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

You can't possibly be talking about Oscar De La Hoya.

[Anthony342]

I maybe wrong but I will say Rocky he usually knocked people.

Yeah but a lot of people believed he didn't deserve the decision in the first Lastarza fight. That's why he defended the title against him and knocked him out, to prove it was no fluke and that he was the better fighter.

[Anthony342]

You can't possibly be talking about Oscar De La Hoya.

Wasn't the Sturm fight controversial for Oscar? Haven't watched it in years.

[LacedUp]

Muhammad Ali (jk).

No one really springs to mind, want to say Gene Tunney, but there were some controversy regarding the long count etc. but it depends on how you define controversy, because he deserved his win. The first Harry Greb was win controversial though.

George Foreman as Marciano are good shouts, mainly because they knocked everyone out. But there were a few as someone mentioned.

And I saw someone mention Floyd and Calzaghe. Not going to lie, I chuckled.

[Scott9945]

Wasn't the Sturm fight controversial for Oscar? Haven't watched it in years.

That was a terrible decision. Sturm was robbed.

[Bolo Punch]

Jones' controversial decision was what? Pavel? I stopped watching him years ago.

I have to apologise for this, I can't even remember posting that and I'm not sure what I even meant by that post.

To clarify what I really think, the only one of the three I thought got a 'gift' was Floyd. I thought Floyd's win over Castillo first time round was very controversial. I had Calzaghe beating Hopkins and Jones beating Tarver the first time, though (assuming that's the fight I was talking about in my original post).

[young_robbed]

You can't possibly be talking about Oscar De La Hoya.

how about his fight against sturm?

[C-ORTIZ]

Wasn't the Sturm fight controversial for Oscar? Haven't watched it in years.

Some will say Strum. Others will say Quartey although I believe Oscar clearly won when he nearly stopped the bur-head in the 12th round.