When was the last time a smaller man beat a good top ten ring magazine ranked larger man on points in a significant fight at heavyweight?

[billeau2]

Usyk doesn’t count because although he was significantly smaller AND won on points, he wasn’t “small enough?”

If you want to kind of get a feel for the logic employed by the OP regarding defining/naming things please see link below:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZ5v...nel=ChrisReise

[_Rexy_]

Does James Toney at HW count? He was just a fat middleweight (what Fury claims Usyk is)

[Ivich]

Too 10 seemed to be the qualifier. I think you’re moving the goalposts aren’t you?

Just a little bit! lol.Its like Birnam Wood in Macbeth every time you look at it its gotten nearer!LOL

[Dr. Z]

That's what I'm saying. I don't think this is nearly as one sided as he anticipated. There have been plenty of examples shown, and there are probably more out there.

If you consider the significant fights and they and elite level than sure. Plenty of examples? We have one vs elite level, and just a few examples in tier two. That isn't plenty and we are going back 30 years here.

[JAB5239]

If you consider the significant fights and they and elite level than sure. Plenty of examples? We have one vs elite level, and just a few examples in tier two. That isn't plenty and we are going back 30 years here.

Is it elite fighters or top 10? You need to make up your mind. And for as little research as I've put into this, those are plenty of example. What exactly is the point you're trying to make anyway?

[JAB5239]

Does James Toney at HW count? He was just a fat middleweight (what Fury claims Usyk is)

If Toney got his we down and came in around 215, 220, I think he would have won both the zRahman fight and first Sam Peter fight.

[QueensburyRules]

- - Currently Michel Hunter freshly kicked out of Boxrec top 10 by Zhang and Hrgovic is ranked 11th.

Like Chris Byrd eating his way to 215, he's bigger able to eat into the 220s now. Still a small heavy and beat some good fighters, but nothing top 10. Was seen in a spar photo with Wilder now at his new 215 wt, and hunter looked considerably more robust than Deyonce.

[The D3vil]

Lots of small heavies have beaten bigger heavies over the years

Michael Spinks
Michael Moorer
Evander Holyfield
David Haye
"Fast" Eddie Chambers

Haye even beat a Valuev who was 100lbs heavier and 10 inches taller.

Dudes like Jack Dempsey & Joe Louis were beating the hell out of bigger dudes 100 years ago.

Stop the nonsense.

[Ivich]

Lots of small heavies have beaten bigger heavies over the years

Michael Spinks
Michael Moorer
Evander Holyfield
David Haye
"Fast" Eddie Chambers

Haye even beat a Valuev who was 100lbs heavier and 10 inches taller.

Dudes like Jack Dempsey & Joe Louis were beating the hell out of bigger dudes 100 years ago.

Stop the nonsense.

Though you are obviously right,the OP has qualified his specifications with a very narrow criteria and every time an example is found to refute his "point?" He moves the goal posts, it's how he operates.
If more examples are found he will restrict the criteria further,

E ,G. They will have to be ginger haired , blue eyed ,south paws, whose names began with D , or some such nonsense.lol.

[JAB5239]

Lots of small heavies have beaten bigger heavies over the years

Michael Spinks
Michael Moorer
Evander Holyfield
David Haye
"Fast" Eddie Chambers

Haye even beat a Valuev who was 100lbs heavier and 10 inches taller.

Dudes like Jack Dempsey & Joe Louis were beating the hell out of bigger dudes 100 years ago.

Stop the nonsense.

Nice call with Chambers who big McCline and Sam Peter.