Your Top Three Mythical Matchups

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Willie Pep 229
    hic sunt dracone
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Mar 2020
    • 6354
    • 2,823
    • 2,767
    • 29,169

    #31
    Originally posted by Ivich
    ps Its Mugabi.
    The James Hard Rock Green fight after taking a thumb in the eye Mugabi wanted to quit that night. His corner Duff and Francis persuaded him to continue.
    Mugabi lost to Duane Thomas on another thumb in the eye injury ,after which he went on a winning spree,winning his next11 fights by stoppage/


    Yeah Hagler ruined Mugabi ,that's why he went on to win the light middleweight title afterwards! lol
    When Mugabi was stopped against Hagler he had been fighting with an injured right hand from the 6th round onwards his hand was very swollen after the fight
    What on Mugabi's resume says he beats Golovkin?
    Mugabi got $320,00 for the Hagler fight in a few weeks he had spent it all.
    Being from the UK I suspect you can appreciate this . . .

    320K - after giving up 45% to manager and trainer and then another 35% of what's left to taxes - he had about 100K left.

    Maybe got burnt with training expenses and scantioning fees as well. Hopefully not.

    Comment

    • them_apples
      Lord
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Aug 2007
      • 9778
      • 1,184
      • 900
      • 41,722

      #32
      Originally posted by Ivich
      ps Its Mugabi.
      The James Hard Rock Green fight after taking a thumb in the eye Mugabi wanted to quit that night. His corner Duff and Francis persuaded him to continue.
      Mugabi lost to Duane Thomas on another thumb in the eye injury ,after which he went on a winning spree,winning his next11 fights by stoppage/


      Yeah Hagler ruined Mugabi ,that's why he went on to win the light middleweight title afterwards! lol
      When Mugabi was stopped against Hagler he had been fighting with an injured right hand from the 6th round onwards his hand was very swollen after the fight
      What on Mugabi's resume says he beats Golovkin?
      Mugabi got $320,00 for the Hagler fight in a few weeks he had spent it all.
      Not sure why I started spelling his name wrong. But Mugabi even in winning a title after didn’t look good and it wasn’t against the same competition. He received permanent damage from Hagler. When you are that broken down and exhausted and get hit like he was getting hit with no defense left - it’s over. He certainly lost a step.

      I won’t argue who wins GGG or Mugabi because we don’t have enough to go by. Gggs resume isn’t strong enough for us to know how he would fair. My only point I am making is Mugabi was a different fighter after Hagler beat him, and I noticed you wrote him off fast likely because of how his career ended up.

      GGG really hasn’t beat very stiff competiton. Unless you give him a Canelo win. Which imo is a totally different type of fight.

      theres actually a dude in my gym who fought GGG. He lost by KO but heres a hint: I live in Canada lol

      Comment

      • them_apples
        Lord
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Aug 2007
        • 9778
        • 1,184
        • 900
        • 41,722

        #33
        Originally posted by Willie Pep 229

        Being from the UK I suspect you can appreciate this . . .

        320K - after giving up 45% to manager and trainer and then another 35% of what's left to taxes - he had about 100K left.

        Maybe got burnt with training expenses and scantioning fees as well. Hopefully not.
        I thought promoters took about 25-30 percent? Then + taxes you get roughly half. At least thats what my old trainer told me. He fought hopkins and lacy. Its different all over just wondering.
        Last edited by them_apples; 08-10-2022, 12:00 PM.

        Comment

        • Willie Pep 229
          hic sunt dracone
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Mar 2020
          • 6354
          • 2,823
          • 2,767
          • 29,169

          #34
          Originally posted by them_apples

          I thought promoters took about 25-30 percent? Then + taxes you get roughly half. At least thats what my old trainer told me. He fought hopkins and lacy. Its different all over just wondering.
          Actuality IDK - it use to be that most fighters had to give up to 33 1/3 % to their manager. Sometimes they then had to fork over another 10% to a trainer.

          Point being I always thought the promoter took his share out of the profits after the fighters were paid their battle money

          Dempsey and Marciano were both losing 50% to their managers Jack Kearns and Al Weill.

          Kearns had Dempsey tied up for ten years (1916-1925), and some believe it was why Dempsey stopped fighting in 1923 and didn't fight again until after January '26. Kearns only got 50% of Dempsey's fight purses. (Marciano had a worst deal with the gangster Al Weill - see below), so Dempsey went to Hollywood where he got 100% of the money earned.

          The Muhammad Ali Law passed by Congress, (steered through by John McCain back in the 1990s ??), disallowed a manager to take more than 33 1/3 % - it also disallowed a promoter to be a fighter's manager, but there were too many loop holes in that regulation, e.g. Don King would act as promoter and his step son would be the guy's manager. Lol Too easy to get around that one.

          Things have changed so IDK, but I do know some things from the past. Such as:

          Rickard offered Dempsey a % of the Carpentier gate instead of a guarantee. Kearns insisted instead on a flat 300K up front. - after the fight created a 1.6 million gate, Dempsey, had he taken the %, would have pulled in 476K, instead of 300K, thus leaving 176K on the table (in Rickard's pockets).

          Rickard made damn sure the newspaper guys knew about it (that's why I know about it) to make Kearns look inept. It was Rickard's first move in stealing Dempsey away from Kearns.

          Also Rickard paid Dempsey 105K for the Brennan fight at MSG. Later in life Rickard would claim it was the only fight he ever lost money on. So I think we can conclude Rickard the promoter got none of Dempsey's purse.

          I believe Ali only got about 44% of his purses (before taxes) after everyone took their piece, and with Ali it was a long list. Not sure about this one.

          Marciano had a lifetime 50-50 split with Al Weill for any of Marciano's income that was boxing related. Stories tell that after retirement Marciano was so angry when he would show up for a speaking engagement. He would tell the sponsor to keep his two thousand dollar check and give him $500 in cash instead. In short Marciano would take $500 less for himself just to stiff Al Weill out of his $1000.

          But since the Muhammad Ali Act was passed by Congress I really don't know the law. I am certain a manager can no longer take a 50-50 split; no lifetime contracts allowed; no promoter can manager the fighter he is promoting. The rest of the regulations I am ignorant of.

          Of course I could be wrong about all of the above except the Kearns-Rickard story. That one played out in the newspapers. The others were stories.



          Comment

          • Willie Pep 229
            hic sunt dracone
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Mar 2020
            • 6354
            • 2,823
            • 2,767
            • 29,169

            #35
            Originally posted by them_apples

            I thought promoters took about 25-30 percent? Then + taxes you get roughly half. At least thats what my old trainer told me. He fought hopkins and lacy. Its different all over just wondering.
            Sorry I just realized what your buddy was saying.

            Yea a promoter takes a percentage of the gate (PPV today) and the fighters split the rest on an agreed %.

            But the fighters then have to pay their people of of that %.

            Comment

            • tokon
              Undisputed Champion
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Feb 2009
              • 7631
              • 1,824
              • 1,263
              • 42,234

              #36
              Originally posted by them_apples

              Which means absolutely nothing. Hagler was a small middleweight so nothing new here. He was barely bigger than Duran. All you have to do is watch them fight and you can see Hagler is by far the more skillful and better trained fighter.
              With today's 24-36hr prefight weighins Hagler would have been a light middle.

              Comment

              • tokon
                Undisputed Champion
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Feb 2009
                • 7631
                • 1,824
                • 1,263
                • 42,234

                #37
                Originally posted by them_apples

                GGG really hasn’t beat very stiff competiton. Unless you give him a Canelo win. Which imo is a totally different type of fight.
                Golovkin can't just be "given" a win he didn't get! But you're right, golovkin hasn't beaten particularly stiff competition, certainly noone to suggest he would have beaten Hagler. Although he would have height, weight and probably strength advantages over him.

                Comment

                • Ivich
                  Banned
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jun 2013
                  • 4377
                  • 1,640
                  • 2,302
                  • 6,015

                  #38
                  Originally posted by them_apples

                  Not sure why I started spelling his name wrong. But Mugabi even in winning a title after didn’t look good and it wasn’t against the same competition. He received permanent damage from Hagler. When you are that broken down and exhausted and get hit like he was getting hit with no defense left - it’s over. He certainly lost a step.

                  I won’t argue who wins GGG or Mugabi because we don’t have enough to go by. Gggs resume isn’t strong enough for us to know how he would fair. My only point I am making is Mugabi was a different fighter after Hagler beat him, and I noticed you wrote him off fast likely because of how his career ended up.

                  GGG really hasn’t beat very stiff competiton. Unless you give him a Canelo win. Which imo is a totally different type of fight.

                  theres actually a dude in my gym who fought GGG. He lost by KO but heres a hint: I live in Canada lol
                  I think GGG's competition is better than Mugabi's and he was a big middle. Mugabi really a light middle. I was at the fights one night and a guy sitting in front of me was wearing a stetson.the action got lively and he stood up I shouted to him to sit down,he turned around looked at me and did so.When the next fight was ready to start he was introduced into the ring as," JohnThe Beast Mugabi, Marvin Hagler's next challenger"

                  Comment

                  • Ivich
                    Banned
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jun 2013
                    • 4377
                    • 1,640
                    • 2,302
                    • 6,015

                    #39
                    Originally posted by Willie Pep 229

                    Being from the UK I suspect you can appreciate this . . .

                    320K - after giving up 45% to manager and trainer and then another 35% of what's left to taxes - he had about 100K left.

                    Maybe got burnt with training expenses and scantioning fees as well. Hopefully not.
                    The $320,000 was after his manager , trainer ,and IRS took their cuts.
                    Last edited by Ivich; 08-11-2022, 05:28 AM.

                    Comment

                    • QueensburyRules
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • May 2018
                      • 21830
                      • 2,354
                      • 17
                      • 187,708

                      #40
                      Originally posted by tokon

                      Golovkin can't just be "given" a win he didn't get! But you're right, golovkin hasn't beaten particularly stiff competition, certainly noone to suggest he would have beaten Hagler. Although he would have height, weight and probably strength advantages over him.
                      - - Marv wasn't ducked like Golovkin was, the new boogyman.

                      Like Marv, a lifetime 160, but he offered his titles to l'l floydy @155 or he comes down to challenge him @154. Offered Wart a title challenge @164, but nope, them modern American boys don't wanna get KOed.

                      Meanwhile, Marv benefits from Leonard, Hearns, and Duran wanting to fight at 160.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP