Do you think Miguel Cotto is underrated?

[Boxingking1511]

In my opinion he is clearly one of the 21st century greatest boxers. What do you guys think of Miguel Cottos legacy? Is he Hall Of Fame level? Is he ATG? 4 division champ. 6 time world champion.

[Smash]

no he gave floyd a red nose

[Ca$ual Fan]

Hall of Fame yes
ATG is a kinda different story

[bluebeam]

Cotto was a very good fighter.

Underrated? Nope.

He beat a good version of mosley
He beat a downside judah
He beat a one eyed margarito
He beat a washed mayorga
He beat a 1 legged martinez

[aboutfkntime]

yep, he is a HOF'er... Cotto had a excellent career

his two biggest losses were almost certainly against cheats

#overachiever

[lopetego]

Most people consider him HOF caliber

only rican fanboys consider him ATG

I'd says he's correctly rated

[GrandpaBernard]

Miguel Cotto is a very good fighter who beat 1 of the 4 great fighters he faced

[lopetego]

Miguel Cotto is a very good fighter who beat 1 of the 4 great fighters he faced

Are you talking about Mosley?

because one legged Maravilla doesn't count

[Tatabanya]

Solid, compact fighter with big balls. Too little noise to be seriously loved by the masses.
I genuinely enjoyed watching several of his fights.

To me, Hall of Famer means nothing. They throw everybody with a pulse in there by now.

[lopetego]

Solid, compact fighter with big balls. Too little noise to be seriously loved by the masses.
I genuinely enjoyed watching several of his fights.

To me, Hall of Famer means nothing. They throw everybody with a pulse in there by now.

Yeah, because they tend to focus on fame more than greatness

fame in the US particularly, fighters that are popular there and bring views and put butts in seats

that's why many genuinely great fighters from Asia never get in

while someone like Gatti is in