Does Manny Pacquiao have a claim to be a Top 3 ATG?

[Lopez_Boxing]

SRR is the most Overrated boxer of all time.

I respectfully disagree. That would have to be mike Tyson

[Lopez_Boxing]

Atg lists are so subjective and with weight classes, different era etc. it’s hard to make a detailed list to me, but I wouldn’t argue with anyone that places manny as high as they want.

[Lopez_Boxing]

I mean you have to actually have a list to answer this question..but he is damn sure one of the greatest

LIAR!!! You like mayweather so according to BScene rules chapter 3 article 3.4: Being a fan of a fighter means you’re a fanboy. Thus you can not and shall not be a fan of any other fighter in previously mentioned fighters weight class

Sorry Larry

[Tails]

There is so much history in boxing that there are plenty of fighters that you could interchange inside the top 10 atg and you can make a valid case for each order.

When I rank a fighter on an all time list I do my best remove any bias I have against them as a fighter whether it be accusations, personal life, or even fighting style. Mainly because there are many decades of boxing I never had the opportunity of growing up in so I am not going to know the details of the politics and common thought that took place in a past era.

To me what makes an ATG is when you look at what they accomplished and say "I don't think I am ever going to see another fighter accomplish that in my lifetime". For example, Pacquiao and Mayweather both make a strong case because truthfully, I am not sure if I am going to see two amazing careers like the ones those two had in my lifetime. And for "any" rebuttal against an obvious ATG the statement is, "if was that easy then why don't others do it".

[hectari]

On paper.....but when you compare ATGs you have to take every detail into account

Should we knock the old guys for fighting fixed fights?

[QueensburyRules]

He not even top 10 ATG.... You have to take into account the careers of other fighters before making these type of claims

- -U sorta milquetoast mane.

Manny also holds ALL the Ring P4P records with noone else in the ballpark...NOONE!!!

Now eat yo mush like a good boy and shush.

[Boxing_1013]

If you say no or definitely no...you should list your top 3 or top 5

[Boxing_1013]

No. His career has been carefully orchestrated.

Imagine the irony of a Canelo fan saying this lol

[Boxing_1013]

The funniest thing about this is, besides Larry, the other Floyd fans are saying he definitely isn't top 3 ATG...and Manny is definitely the best name on Floyd's resume...so in a way they are actually shi.ting on Floyd lol...people are so blinded with hate for other fighters and support for their own that they don't even make any sense.

Just in a ball of rage and fury...can't see the big picture.

[Boxing_1013]

none of that garbage is criteria for greatness

WHO did you beat... with consideration given to when/how

only idiot pac-tards talk like that... Pac is not even top 3 of the 2000's

How can you say Manny didn't beat some great fighters, and as a very small guy, all the way up to JMW I believe...I mean if you sh.it on Manny you have to really sh.it on Floyd too...makes 0 sense man.