Is Jose Luis Castillo an atg?

[Fonseca17]

Kryptonite to the shoulder roll

[kidbazooka]

At 135 yes ans let’s not forget he did kO corralles in the rematch.

[pasawayako]

He's not even a hall of famer. A class B- at best..

[IronDanHamza]

He had a pretty good resume. He fought good opposition...won some, lost some but atg, imo he is not.

Ok.

Who had a better resume from his era?

Could you name 20 others in history with better ones?

Even if you could it wouldn't be easy.

[Real King Kong]

Ok.

Who had a better resume from his era?

Could you name 20 others in history with better ones?

Even if you could it wouldn't be easy.

Sure, but head to head, what atg lw fighters would you pick Castillo over?

[UNBIASED BOXING]

Not an ATG.

[_Rexy_]

Or Whitaker beat Chávez or williams beat Lara

You don't compare those two fights to a 50/50 fight like Floyd/Castillo.


Lara beat Williams like 11-1

[_Rexy_]

At 135 yes ans let’s not forget he did kO corralles in the rematch.

Yeah, but that first fight took years off both guys lives. I don't even think Diego won a fight after that war, did he?

[killakali]

U lost me there bud lol

lol a lot of people had the first floy vs Maidana fight a close chino win or a draw

[killakali]

You don't compare those two fights to a 50/50 fight like Floyd/Castillo.


Lara beat Williams like 11-1

Floyd castillo 1 was like 70/30 castillo. Watch the fight again and look at the punch stats.