Is Jose Luis Castillo an atg?

[Fat_asian]

I mean he got blown out by hatton (body shots) he was in there with the great Diego corrales, arguably beat pbfm the best of his era and he was the chief sparring partner for jcc. Not to go against the late great Manny steward, Lord bless, but what do you guys think? Or is he a waste of talent who could've achieved much more but lost it on the scales??

[IronDanHamza]

At Lightweight yes.

[Outwest Exp 355]

I don’t think so. Good fighter but lacked in professionalism. Missed weight a lot of times.

[Madison Boxing]

He clearly beat Floyd who some people say is one of the best ever so I would say so

[IronDanHamza]

He clearly beat Floyd who some people say is one of the best ever so I would say so

All three judges had him winning.

Isn't that what you go off?

[Madison Boxing]

All three judges had him winning.

Isn't that what you go off?

Castillo won that fight

[IronDanHamza]

Castillo won that fight

......But the three judges had him losing.

Isn't that what you go off?

Or only when it fits your extremely transparent agenda?

[KillaMane26]

If yall gon say he beat Floyd then i hope the same people say the same for fights like GGG vs Canelo

[Madison Boxing]

......But the three judges had him losing.

Isn't that what you go off?

Or only when it fits your extremely transparent agenda?

Judges aren't always right all I'm saying 'dan' is that Eubank Saunders was a close fight where people were unsure who won, mayweather castillo 1 was close too but had a clear winner.

[IronDanHamza]

Judges aren't always right all I'm saying 'dan' is that Eubank Saunders was a close fight where people were unsure who won, mayweather castillo 1 was close too but had a clear winner.

You justified that by saying "one of the judges had Eubank winning" yet all 3 had Floyd winning Are you purposely missing that gigantic double standard or do you genuinely not see it?

People were not unsure who won. That is again a LIE. The vast majority had Saunders winning. That is a FACT.

In fact, an example of a fight where people were unsure who won is Mayweather-Castillo 1, where the press row media were split 50-50 on who won.

Barely anyone, if anyone thought Eubank beat Saunders.

These are facts.