-Be honest....Did Floyd beat Castillo?

[VatoMulatto]

Castillo vs Mayweather I

I think that's the only fight in Floyd's career where you can make a pretty damn good argument that Floyd did not win.

Did anyone on this site score the fight for Floyd?

[4truth]

I thought it was Floyd's only fight he did not win clearly, I thought it was a clear loss.

[powershots]

I thought he lost the first Castillo fight. He readjusted and beat him the second time.

[GrandpaBernard]

Floyd swept early rounds and they split the rounds in the 2nd half.

Castillo was too deep in the hole to win

Floyd did the right thing by rematching him immediately. Compare that to modern fighters who get gifts in an outright robbery and duck the rematch for the rest of their career

[Madison Boxing]

He Lost the first fight and sc****d a win in the second. There should have been a 3rd

[lizard_man]

I thought maidana beat floyd 7-5 first fight.

[_Maxi]

Floyd swept early rounds and they split the rounds in the 2nd half.

Castillo was too deep in the hole to win

Floyd did the right thing by rematching him immediately. Compare that to modern fighters who get gifts in an outright robbery and duck the rematch for the rest of their career

We're not talking about rematches. Rematches have no effect on the real result of the first encounter.

[Beercules]

Castillo beat him the first time.



Maidana 1 was a draw.

[IronDanHamza]

First fight was either way.

Second fight Floyd won.

[therealpugilist]

Castillo vs Mayweather I

I think that's the only fight in Floyd's career where you can make a pretty damn good argument that Floyd did not win.

Did anyone on this site score the fight for Floyd?

a better question would be who actually watch the entire fight instead of highlights