NSB: Do you understand now why Carnelo is #1 P4P? DO YOU?

[Boxing101_]

Resume. WHO DID YOU BEAT?

How many times does this guy have to show up before you believe?

Terence Crawford has NO win anywhere close to that. Neither does Loma. In a weight class he's never fought at.

Canelo didnt beat any of the greats in their prime. ***** Terry Noris beat sugar ray leonard while he was even younger than what kovalev is now. We all know Terry Noris wouldnt stand a chance against a prime Leonard. Does this Make Terry Noris P4P, great?????? So when you apply this to Canelo's situation, then I really dont see they hype at all, Dude fights everyone when they are old and not the same fighter anymore.

[Combat Talk Radio]

Canelo didnt beat any of the greats in their prime. ***** Terry Noris beat sugar ray leonard while he was even younger than what kovalev is now. We all know Terry Noris wouldnt stand a chance against a prime Leonard. Does this Make Terry Noris P4P, great?????? So when you apply this to Canelo's situation, then I really dont see they hype at all, Dude fights everyone when they are old and not the same fighter anymore.

NOBODY disputes Terrible's status in the ATG rankings. Same with guys like Larry Holmes.

[BoxingIsGreat]

Unfortunately that is the nature of sport's forums. I am not a Canelo hater but a Bivol win would have been more impressive. The fight was offered and Canelo politely declined. It was a smart business decision to fight Kovalev but should it enhance his resume much? Kovalev barely beat a fatigued, inexperienced Yarde and then took this fight on a short layoff. The K.O was impressive but Canelo didn't look very scintillating except for the 11th round. No hating just stating facts! IMHO pound for pound lists are nonsense! Is Canelo the most exciting current fighter? Where is that list?

The bolded: Great question. Green K.
P4P is the biggest BS and an empty name.

Each fan has favorite boxers, semi favorite boxers, and neutrals (where you don't care how it ends, but you still like the fighters).

These are some of my favorite top notch fighters (call it my P4P list if you like). I know I'll leave some out. No number or order:


Gervonta Davis
Katie Taylor
Usyk
Lubin
Lomachenko
Spence
Canelo
Crawford
Estrada
Naoya Inoue


War Boxing!

[Alan Smithee]

The bolded: Great question. Green K.
P4P is the biggest BS and an empty name.

Each fan has favorite boxers, semi favorite boxers, and neutrals (where you don't care how it ends, but you still like the fighters).

These are some of my favorite top notch fighters (call it my P4P list if you like). I know I'll leave some out. No number or order:


Gervonta Davis
Katie Taylor
Usyk
Lubin
Lomachenko
Spence
Canelo
Crawford
Estrada
Naoya Inoue


War Boxing!

Great list! As far as Katie Taylor, I am all for women's rights but not for women's fights. The women bore me to tears. Just speaking from the heart.

[BoxingIsGreat]

Great list! As far as Katie Taylor, I am all for women's rights but not for women's fights. The women bore me to tears. Just speaking from the heart.

Thank you for your honesty. I respect that.

I love all boxing. I enjoy women's boxing. I know them just as well as the guys. Katie is my girl, so are Claressa and Serrano. Amazing ladies.

[Alan Smithee]

Thank you for your honesty. I respect that.

I love all boxing. I enjoy women's boxing. I know them just as well as the guys. Katie is my girl, so are Claressa and Serrano. Amazing ladies.

I respect your opinion as well. Although there have been recent ring tragedies there is nothing like boxing! Continue to enjoy the sport! I know that I will!

[Combat Talk Radio]

Great list! As far as Katie Taylor, I am all for women's rights but not for women's fights. The women bore me to tears. Just speaking from the heart.

The women actually let their hands go. Every time. Just sayin

[Combat Talk Radio]

Now we have cats criticizing Kov's jab despite the fact that it's all he COULD do, lest he get brutally countered by the Carne Franchise Champion.

[Combat Talk Radio]

And a big thank you to the big three - including Crawford's own ESPN - for finally coming back to your senses.

[MEXICAN STYLE]

Resume. WHO DID YOU BEAT?

How many times does this guy have to show up before you believe?

Terence Crawford has NO win anywhere close to that. Neither does Loma. In a weight class he's never fought at.

Besides resume Alvarez should be P4P King alone just for saving boxing after Mayweather retired like Canelo's next opponent's identity is anticipated unlike DSG vs Ivan, William's fight among others