NSB: Do you understand now why Carnelo is #1 P4P? DO YOU?

[Combat Talk Radio]

Resume. WHO DID YOU BEAT?

How many times does this guy have to show up before you believe?

Terence Crawford has NO win anywhere close to that. Neither does Loma. In a weight class he's never fought at.

[Combat Talk Radio]

I now wish to see Carnelo vs. Eubank Jr. Just for the hell of it.

I actually think Young Eubank would put up a much better fight than Kov but end up getting knocked out too. Maybe that's why.

[Johnny2x2x]

Canelo is putting in an all time great career. I don’t think he should stay at 175, but he can dominate at 168 IMO.

He’s done more than anyone to be P4P #1.

[ralex]

Easily #1 p4p

[Hobo]

If Canelo became the heavyweight champion he would still be hated on.

[Combat Talk Radio]

If Canelo became the heavyweight champion he would still be hated on.

Could you imagine...Carnelo beats Ruiz, becomes unified : "AJ softened him up"

I'm seriously waiting for people to justify rating him below Crawford.

[Simurgh]

Agree, he should be no.1

[Johnny2x2x]

I had picked Kovalev to win and he was on his way to that, I had him up 6-4. He was using his reach and jab and fighting a smart fight. I thought he had it won. For Canelo to KO the bigger man that decisively, that’s an all time resume builder.

[Combat Talk Radio]

I had picked Kovalev to win and he was on his way to that, I had him up 6-4. He was using his reach and jab and fighting a smart fight. I thought he had it won. For Canelo to KO the bigger man that decisively, that’s an all time resume builder.

But some will still call Crawford #1 for no damn reason.

[Citizen Koba]

But some will still call Crawford #1 for no damn reason.

The reason is that it's entirely subjective. This is the reason I don't subscribe to P4P at all.

If you're asking the question 'who has the best resume in the sport?' then it's obviously between Canelo and Pac' but if you're asking the question 'who would win if they were the same size?' which is how P4P is most often phrased, then anyone's free to pick who the hell they like. That **** can never be proved one way or another unless the guys actually are the same size and get in the ring together.