Name the fights you feel Canelo shouldnt have got the W for?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ramses07
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Apr 2011
    • 2006
    • 226
    • 88
    • 23,870

    #51
    Besides Mayweather

    Only GGG 1

    Lara is someone that never rises to the occasion.

    Comment

    • daggum
      All time great
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Feb 2008
      • 43871
      • 4,742
      • 3
      • 166,270

      #52
      he lost to mosley. larry mosley

      Comment

      • boliodogs
        Undisputed Champion
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • May 2008
        • 33358
        • 824
        • 1,782
        • 309,589

        #53
        I thought Canelo lost to Mayweather by about 7 or 8 points. I thought he lost the first fight to GGG by 4 points and I thought he lost the 2nd fight to GGG by two points. I thought Canelo beat Lara by 2 points and he beat Trout by 4 points and beat Cotto by 6 points. I scored all these fights carefully and tried to be fair to both fighters. I think Canelo has improved a lot with every fight and I expect him to KO Jacobs even thought Jacobs is better than Mayweather, Lara, Trout and Cotto were when Canelo fought them. His steady improvement fight after fight has amazed me. Canelo always gets generous scoring in Vagas. That is just a fact. But it's not as bad as some say. if Jacobs can really win 8 of the 12 rounds I think he will get a win. If Jacobs only wins 7 rounds he will probably be lucky to get a draw. But maybe the judges will be more fair this fight. Anyway I think Canelo wins by KO or by a clear deserved ud.

        Comment

        • BoxingIsGreat
          The Champ
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Feb 2009
          • 19470
          • 1,684
          • 2,397
          • 1,062,888

          #54
          Only one loss: Floyd.

          Comment

          • Bjl12
            Banned
            • Sep 2016
            • 4952
            • 185
            • 28
            • 59,933

            #55
            Title of thread is which Canelo W (meaning WIN) should've been a LOSS.

            Mayweather was a loss and should've been a LOSS. No clue why people are mentioning that fight.

            Lara and GGG1 shouldve been draws although GGG1 couldve been a loss (7-5). I have no problem with ungrateful Lara getting L in that fight as he literally ran around like it was a track meet

            The KD in Trout was the difference maker

            Cotto fight was either 8-4 or 7-5. A draw would be very, very biased. I cant even imagine a world where Cotto beat Canelo...insanity

            GGG2 was accurate as is. A draw wouldve also been acceptable. GGG did not win the rematch, but he may've drawn

            It's a shame so many posters are THAT immature where they just make things up to fit their agenda. Kind of reminds me of the 6 year stretch between 2009-2015 when Manny fights would just make things up and run with it...running into a wide UD Loss ultimately.

            Comment

            • Bjl12
              Banned
              • Sep 2016
              • 4952
              • 185
              • 28
              • 59,933

              #56
              Originally posted by boliodogs
              I thought Canelo lost to Mayweather by about 7 or 8 points. I thought he lost the first fight to GGG by 4 points and I thought he lost the 2nd fight to GGG by two points. I thought Canelo beat Lara by 2 points and he beat Trout by 4 points and beat Cotto by 6 points. I scored all these fights carefully and tried to be fair to both fighters.
              This clown is just bad for boxing and probably bad for humanity.

              Literally every score (besides Floyd) is flat out wrong

              Floyd winning 10-2 or 9-3 = correct

              GGG1 8-4 or 116-112 = Not even the lone GGG judge had it that wide. Dave Moretti (who Abel and Gennady hand-selected for the rematch) score it 7-5 or 115-113.

              GGG2 "by two points" is another way of saying "I dont know how fights are scored or how to judge a fight". Having a fighter win "by two points" is the same as them winning by 1 round. Regardless - that's an unacceptable score

              Trout by 4 and Cotto by 6 show how bad you are at scoring fights. Lara by 2 is also pretty bad.

              Comment

              • BigStomps
                Banned
                • Sep 2016
                • 7829
                • 259
                • 1
                • 82,514

                #57
                Originally posted by TonyGe
                You're funny. As far as me shutting up forget it. Not going to happen. Did it ever occur to you that Nacho and Marquez who are well respected
                in the boxing community aren't just going to go along with the Canelo worship. They are just telling it as they see it.
                Punk they don't have to worship another man but at least give respect where it's due! It's a big difference!
                Like I said, you aren't Mexican, you don't watch the Spanish sport's shows and I'm sure you don't even speak Spanish....
                But you ask any other men who does speak Spanish and watches the Spanish sport's shows and they'll tell you the same thing I did.
                Marquez and Nacho find every opportunity to hate on Canelo. The same way you do!
                But we all know why you keep hating... It's just the biitch in you!

                Comment

                • BigStomps
                  Banned
                  • Sep 2016
                  • 7829
                  • 259
                  • 1
                  • 82,514

                  #58
                  Originally posted by chirorickyp
                  they are jealous salty MFers.
                  They are! Marquez and Nacho always hating on Canelo! They feel Canelo got everything handed to him and he didn't earn it the way Marquez did... I'll agree that Canelo was given a title opportunity he probably didn't deserve but how they gonna blame Canelo for that???
                  If they wanna blame someone then blame the WBC! And you know they salty that at such a young age Canelo was already a huge star in Mexico and in the United States and earning millions in the process while Marquez had it rough and didn't start making millions till his late 30's... I like and respect Marquez but how you gonna hate on another man for that??
                  Marquez and Nacho always hating on Canelo and that's fucced up cause they are two of my favorite fighters....

                  Comment

                  • chirorickyp
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Apr 2007
                    • 1514
                    • 67
                    • 10
                    • 27,945

                    #59
                    Originally posted by BigStomps
                    They are! Marquez and Nacho always hating on Canelo! They feel Canelo got everything handed to him and he didn't earn it the way Marquez did... I'll agree that Canelo was given a title opportunity he probably didn't deserve but how they gonna blame Canelo for that???
                    If they wanna blame someone then blame the WBC! And you know they salty that at such a young age Canelo was already a huge star in Mexico and in the United States and earning millions in the process while Marquez had it rough and didn't start making millions till his late 30's... I like and respect Marquez but how you gonna hate on another man for that??
                    Marquez and Nacho always hating on Canelo and that's fucced up cause they are two of my favorite fighters....
                    To me they think they are equal to Canelo. I don't think Canelo is charismatic, but apparently millions do since he is truly a PPV star. He became a star on his own. Marquez was great counter puncher but has no X factor of any kind. Had it not been for his Pacquiao fights he would be as well known as a Castillo. Not a PPV attraction ever and he can't figure out why since he worked so hard and acheived greatness in the ring. Canelo's record speaks for itself, he didn't need a B side for any of his fights. Even Mayweather made money on Canelo's coattails otherwise it would be 300K PPV sales like he had against Berto. Marquez career is not memorable at all once you take Manny's name off. That's why he's jealous. When I say this I am not knocking the man or his abiliity. He was a great.

                    Comment

                    • Sid-Knee
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                      • Oct 2015
                      • 18249
                      • 1,091
                      • 731
                      • 155,532

                      #60
                      Canelo lost to Gx2 and Lara. Had it pretty clear for Canelo against both Trout and Cotto.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP