Not buying it. All that counts is wins and losses in the record books. There are NO moral wins in sports or life. And you don’t get additional wins on your record for “not ducking.” And there is no such thing as could’ve, should’ve, would’ve. Again, all that really counts are wins & losses. He loss to Mosley. He loss to Trinidad. And that wasn’t the same Chavez in his prime before he lost to Frankie Randall. Vargas is not a P4P great or Future HOF’er. And we aren’t talking about Olympics, I am talking about his professional career which is what Oscar mentioned in the article. (2) great wins, Quartey & Whitaker period.
And the really great fighters in history don’t have a total of (6) losses against other great fighters IN THEIR PRIME. And great fighters historically avenge losses also. You don’t get extra credit for challenging great fighters and losing to them.
If that’s the case, let’s just go ahead and put Fernando Vargas in the HOF right now and call him a GREAT FIGHTER. He has only (5) losses total to Shane Mosley twice, Ricardo Mayorga, Felix Trinidad, and Oscar De La Hoya. But he has just as many great wins as Oscar against Ike Quartey and Winky Wright. And he has some other decent wins against Yori Boy Campas, Raul Marquez, and Wilfredo Rivera.
I could make the argument that “professionally” Vargas WINS are just as good as Oscars. I’m just talking about wins which is what Oscar brought up when he alluded to having a bunch of great wins. But neither one is great to me.
And the really great fighters in history don’t have a total of (6) losses against other great fighters IN THEIR PRIME. And great fighters historically avenge losses also. You don’t get extra credit for challenging great fighters and losing to them.
If that’s the case, let’s just go ahead and put Fernando Vargas in the HOF right now and call him a GREAT FIGHTER. He has only (5) losses total to Shane Mosley twice, Ricardo Mayorga, Felix Trinidad, and Oscar De La Hoya. But he has just as many great wins as Oscar against Ike Quartey and Winky Wright. And he has some other decent wins against Yori Boy Campas, Raul Marquez, and Wilfredo Rivera.
I could make the argument that “professionally” Vargas WINS are just as good as Oscars. I’m just talking about wins which is what Oscar brought up when he alluded to having a bunch of great wins. But neither one is great to me.
Comment