Comments Thread For: James Toney: I Would Have Knocked Bernard Hopkins Out!

[Removed Now]

Without a doubt in my mind he would beat both fighters.

I could see the GGG going 12 rounds, idk who wins. He would beat Kelly.

[jonnyc420]

Man, James Toney was one of my favorite fighters of all time. Sad that he stuck around so long.

[SteveM]

Would had been an interesting fight. But could Toney beat GGG or Kelly Pavlik?

I got it 65-35 in favor of Toney over GGG and 75-25 over Pavlik

Toney is too athletic for both of them and too 'in their face'

[Removed Now]

I got it 65-35 in favor of Toney over GGG and 75-25 over Pavlik

Toney is too athletic for both of them and too 'in their face'

I like how you broke it down.

[j.razor]

I agree with the Pavlik results. Not too sure with stopping GGG. I Def think he's not stopping b hop.

golovkin is EASY to hit so "Lights Out" would happen.

[McNulty]

Look, Toney was good but he ain't knocking Hopkins out.

[vitali1999]

Hopkins would have won by unanimous decision

[IronDanHamza]

James Toney couldn't knock out (or beat) Montel Griffin and couldn't knock out Williams, Sosa, Tiberi etc and I am supposed to believe that he could knock out Hopkins?

[IronDanHamza]

I was at the Toney-Nunn fight in a AAA baseball diamond in Davenport Iowa. What a great fight it was! Toney was the beginning of the end for Nunns career. Met Angelo Dundee as well. What a trainer! Toney is definitely one of the GOAT. Another fighter whose achievements eclipse Mayweather's. Many people on this site became fans of boxing because of Mayweather and know very little about the Greats and future GOATs in the 80's and 90's. Nunn was exceptional but Toney blew him out of his shoes. Unfortunately, Toney just like RJJ stayed too long. You need to look past that and look at what he did and how he did it.

Comedian.

[b00g13man]

"James Toney: I Would Have Knocked Bernard Hopkins Out!"

Story of his career really.