Is Mayweather the GOAT 154 lbs and under fighter?

[chrisJS]

But somehow Floyd at 38 was prime? and you said Mosley lost to Forrest and Winky?? so???? Barrera had lost to ****ing Junior Jones 2 times and Morales

He also beat Morales twice and Morales is greater than those two combined. Jones lost to Barrera before he'd even had his signature wins Hamed and Morales and before he'd unified.

[Larry the boss]

He also beat Morales twice and Morales is greater than those two combined. Jones lost to Barrera before he'd even had his signature wins Hamed and Morales and before he'd unified.

you named 3 losses and I named 3 losses..now you wanna make excuses Mosley beat Oscar 2 times as well and was p4p #1 at one time..stop being biased just to discredit fighters its pathetic

[chrisJS]

you named 3 losses and I named 3 losses..now you wanna make excuses Mosley beat Oscar 2 times as well and was p4p #1 at one time..stop being biased just to discredit fighters its pathetic

He was considered by Ring as #1 in 2000 but most considered Roy Jones or even Trinidad #1. I named FIVE losses. 5. He also got a bit of a gift against Oscar in 2003 whilst admittedly on roids. You really think his absolute prime was 2010 off a 16 month layoff don't you?

Roy Jones was #1 in 2004 as was Hopkins that year too Calzaghe beat both 4 years after (4 years is less than 10) but rightfully didn't get full credit and in the case of Hopkins he actually accomplished WAY more AFTER losing to Joe than Mosley accomplished after De La Hoya I in the year 2000. You use ring p4p is gospel when it suits you but the same publication had Pac #1 until 2011 and has ggg there now I'm sure you didn't/don't agree with that?

[IronDanHamza]

Here's a question;

Does anyone really honestly think Jimmy Wilde is greater than Floyd Mayweather or we just throwing some of these names in for comedic value?

I mean, Ruben Olivares, ranked higher than Floyd Mayweather? Please.......

[chrisJS]

Here's a question;

Does anyone really honestly think Jimmy Wilde is greater than Floyd Mayweather or we just throwing some of these names in for comedic value?

I mean, Ruben Olivares, ranked higher than Floyd Mayweather? Please.......

Most the posters here have never heard of Jimmy Wilde or Olivares for that matter.

[Larry the boss]

He was considered by Ring as #1 in 2000 but most considered Roy Jones or even Trinidad #1. I named FIVE losses. 5. He also got a bit of a gift against Oscar in 2003 whilst admittedly on roids. You really think his absolute prime was 2010 off a 16 month layoff don't you?

Roy Jones was #1 in 2004 as was Hopkins that year too Calzaghe beat both 4 years after (4 years is less than 10) but rightfully didn't get full credit and in the case of Hopkins he actually accomplished WAY more AFTER losing to Joe than Mosley accomplished after De La Hoya I in the year 2000. You use ring p4p is gospel when it suits you but the same publication had Pac #1 until 2011 and has ggg there now I'm sure you didn't/don't agree with that?

who said he was prime in 2010?? I said he was the top ww and p4p #3 and WBA champ which are all facts

[Larry the boss]

Here's a question;

Does anyone really honestly think Jimmy Wilde is greater than Floyd Mayweather or we just throwing some of these names in for comedic value?

I mean, Ruben Olivares, ranked higher than Floyd Mayweather? Please.......

Hell no, dude discredits everything Floyd has done in his entire career..

[chrisJS]

who said he was prime in 2010?? I said he was the top ww and p4p #3 and WBA champ which are all facts

You've said it before. P4p is never a fact. It's a mythical ranking.

Is GGG the p4p #1 right now? That same publication says so so is that fact? Also that same magazine rated Pac as the #1 welter and p4p fighter that that time so your "facts" are mixed up.

[Larry the boss]

Most the posters here have never heard of Jimmy Wilde or Olivares for that matter.

Jimmy Wilde was a damn Euro champ for crying out loud

[Xi_]

Most the posters here have never heard of Jimmy Wilde or Olivares for that matter.

The answer to his question is no....