Comments Thread For: Closing Out 2017: BoxingScene Pound For Pound

[bronx7]

So now you think Mikey Garcia should not be on top 10 pfp at all? So boxing scene who you troll is wrong 10 experts on ESPN are wrong only you who constantly picks losers in fights then deny it your right? Cute I don’t buy it

[bronx7]

Mike Garcia 1st fight back beat a contender. 2nd fight won lightweight belt from undefeated champ. 3rd beat Broner at his best title winning weight 140. Will take lipinets belt then will beat Linares not bad jerjoff& ha?

[crold1]

Debate is not needed for this P4P list, but what is needed is sanity check of the author - Cliff Rold.
I think the guy has some mental issues.

Because you don’t agree with me on a totally subjective list of fighters that largely can’t fight each other?

Thanks doctor but I think I’m okay.

[bronx7]

This dude who made boxingscene pfp list is the managing editor. Imagine this crazy guy has to approve the other writers articles before printing. Wow Badou Jack over Spence , Kovalev and can name 5 others better. Espn 10 experts Badou not even on second 10 so not Top 20 wow

[bronx7]

Inmates running the asylum

[crold1]

This dude who made boxingscene pfp list is the managing editor. Imagine this crazy guy has to approve the other writers articles before printing. Wow Badou Jack over Spence , Kovalev and can name 5 others better. Espn 10 experts Badou not even on second 10 so not Top 20 wow

Didn’t 3 of those ESPN guys have Deontay Wilder in their top ten?

[BoxngLove]

Badou Jack over Spence, Kovalev , must I go o

You could also post just once instead of 4x in a row to bump everyone else's comments out.

Rungsavai has been wollopped in most of cases when he stepped up. I think Estrada is a complete fighter with very little to take away from his skill. B.Jack, is probably getting a lot of credit for stepping up on weight class and dominating 1 opponent, but he definitely has skills. Mikey is a true talent, but all the time off and hodge-podge of opponents is also strange to evaluate. I will say it is a nice list. Probably the most debatable topic of all, next to who is the GOAT.

[Lester Tutor]

Dayumz... Cliff Rold got owned. New media posters owning these journalists...

He said "Cult of Rigo" followers. He could've said "cult of Rigo followers knowing what it is for a fighter jumping up two classes daring to be great when the other lower ranked fighter never dared for the catch."

When Floma loses to Garcia...he'll always wonder why journalism, fanboyism, and karma strikes a chord

[deanrw]

I think Loma has to be in everyone's top 3 no matter how you slice it. Not only does he look super talented, but his body of work is also getting up there.

[Pigeons]

1. Lomachenko
2. Crawford
3. M. Garcia
4. Canelo
5. Golovkin
6. Thurman
7. Sor Rungvisai
8. Inoue
9. LSC
10. Kovalev

Spence and the Charlos are right on the cusp.