Comments Thread For: Closing Out 2017: BoxingScene Pound For Pound

[My Low Place]

Sorry list is suspect Badou Jack? Please give me a break over Spence talent wise

badou jack should be on the list..look at his last 5 fights..no one has fought a tougher schedule likely...
and he won them all imo...

put some respect on his name!

hell name u're list since u have all the answers..i'll swat that crap out of here quick!

[My Low Place]

Hahaha! Terence Crawford at number one is a stretch. I realised we are being trolled when I saw Mikey Garcia at number three. The list just gets worse from here. Juan Francisco Estrada? Badou Jack? Whoever made this list should be put on gardening leave.

garcia should not be on any list...3 years out of the sport an dhis best win since is broner. I AGREE HE'S A NO GO...and a win over salido that he couldnt finish bc he watned to quit? na!

Badou jack is deserving his last 5 fights are the hardest 5 of anyone active...if groves wins the 168 tourney his resume looks even better...he battered degale..i have jack as my #3

[My Low Place]

Badou Jack in the ten? Seriously? There are a wealth of names more deserving. First and foremost is Usyk.

Badou Jack is my #3....name someone who's last 5 opponents were harder than his...badou jack has fought just as many current of former champ than crawford has....and no bute or degale wasnt a draw...he killed both men...went up to 175 and blasted out cleverly as well who had just stopped breahmer

[My Low Place]

Fake fans wake up your own site boxingscene gives Mikey Garcia the respect you don’t #3 pound for pound in the world!!! You can say you think he cherry picks your wrong but you can say it but give his elite talent respect

mikey garcia SHOULDNT HAVE FANS...wtf are u supposed to be a fan of? fighting broner? WHO GIVES A FUG ABOUT BRONER?

he took 3 years away from the sport and he really didnt do anything of note before he left...gamboa was meant to be his real test and he ran off...salido made him quit!

[oscar9992]

Mikey Garcia is ahead of Loma? Hahaha!

Luckily Mikey is a lot bigger than Loma & fights two divisions above otherwise he would get introduced into High-Tech. school of boxing.

[mvooom]

The is a terrible list boxingscene. Terrible!

So because Rigo lost in a fight were he moves up 2 weight classes to face a magician, he automatically gets ejected off the list?

"...silence the cult of Rigo" sounds like what a hater on the forums will say. Even if I accept Rigo gone due to lack fights to qualify with, this list is still terrible.

GGG vs Canelo fight. The rounds GGG won and the rounds Canelo won, which showed better fighter? Or does the writer just like KOs? GGG only won rounds were fatigue killed Canelo which are the middle rounds only, that is truly it. No other way around that, if Canelo gets his stamina up, it will be a clean wash.

How can Loma not be 1 or 2 behind Crawford and Crawford only? I don't get it.

Writer had Mikey above Loma, even if Loma will lose to Mikey when they fight, doesn't mean much as of right now. P4P does not mean if small fighter moves up or big fighter moves down, it means if they all NATURALLY weighed the same.

Thurman but no Spence? Smh.

The most annoying article so far. A nice way to close 2017 boxingscene.

We need a general definition of P4P and how fighters should be ranked or even better, we need 2 list one ranked by eye test and the other by resume. Mixing both causes unnecessary confusion.

[oscar9992]

The is a terrible list boxingscene. Terrible!

So because Rigo lost in a fight were he moves up 2 weight classes to face a magician, he automatically gets ejected off the list?

"...silence the cult of Rigo" sounds like what a hater on the forums will say. Even if I accept Rigo gone due to lack fights to qualify with, this list is still terrible.

GGG vs Canelo fight. The rounds GGG won and the rounds Canelo won, which showed better fighter? Or does the writer just like KOs? GGG only won rounds were fatigue killed Canelo which are the middle rounds only, that is truly it. No other way around that, if Canelo gets his stamina up, it will be a clean wash.

How can Loma not be 1 of 2 behind Crawford and Crawford only? I don't get it.

Writer had Mikey above Loma, even if Loma will lose to Mikey when they fight, doesn't mean much as of right now. P4P does not mean if small fighter moves up or big fighter moves down, it means if they all NATURALLY weighed the same.

Thurman but no Spence? Smh.

The most annoying article so far. A nice way to close 2017 boxingscene.

We need a general definition of P4P and how fighters should be ranked or even better, we need 2 list one ranked by eye test and the other by resume. Mixing both causes unnecessary confusion.

This... Mikey does NOT belong to Top 3 P4P.

[Dean_Razorback]

loma should be number 1, and lol at GGG and mikey above him

[Madison Boxing]

really bizarre list, dont know where to start with that. im a big mikey fan but number 3? seriously? i know p4p is subjective but how can that be justified? Badou jack number 10? Wtf lol, whos he actually beat, hes probably not in the top 3 of his own division. i dont follow the flyweights or whatever division that is much but how can estrada be ahead of sor rungvasai? surely rungavasais the top dog in that division now.

[DuckAdonis]

Real ****ty list