Mayweather at Middlweight?

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • DLT
    DMV
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Nov 2004
    • 17087
    • 737
    • 35
    • 24,277

    #41
    Originally posted by Smokin'
    Man, you're still thinking in your little Mayweather box. You're a credible boxer, but you gotta get some diversity in the fighter's you watch. It is true in the amateurs that the best 'boxers' win, but in the pro game this is way ****ing different. You cannot win on just size/speed alone.

    Ok, let me make this simple for you. Zab RAN from 140 lbs to get away from Kosta Tszyu and Floyd Mayweather. It's that simple. He had no competition at 147 so he was able to get all of the belts there and get a leg up on Floyd on the negotiations table. Only problem was, Baldomir foiled Zab's plan on making the biggest payday of his career. Same thing with Sharmba. Mayweather fought a very credible, formidable opponent in Sharmba but he's a career 140 lber. He's not even fighting naturals. He's just conning dumb ****s like yourself.

    And yeah, I never really looked into the Oscar - Mayorga fight. I didn't really care for the matchup and I knew Oscar was gong to outclass Mayorga. I wasn't overly impressed with Oscar at 154 there, he seemed out of shape and he was fighting just a terrble one-trick pony in Mayorga. I do know Floyd is a different machine, but give Oscar a little bit of credit here. He's an olympic gold medalist, a 6 weight world champ, I think he would figure Floyd out pretty damn easily.

    And I will bet my 2 balls that Mayweather will never beat Taylor. Taylor is uncoordinated, but the guy is an athletic freak. He's not your regular 160 lber. He's a weight-drained super middleweight who has the potential probably to win titles at 168, 175. He is a decent boxer, but he is an athletic monster. Floyd wouldn't even touch Taylor.

    And Winky is small himself, I think that's why you're giving Floyd the benefit of the doubt. Floyd never once had the intention of fighting Winky. I remember a while back I had SOLID proof that Floyd blatantly ducked Winky. Basically, Winky took a deal and Floyd pulled a Roy Jones and wanted more money and a bigger split in his favour.
    1st off you need to stop talking to me like Im some littile kid. I dont just watch Floyd or guys who are slick. I watch all boxing and know alot about each fighter.

    2nd, you are wrong about Zab. You can say what you want about him but to say he ran from Tszyu and Floyd is ******. Zab has been trying to get a Tszyu fight ever since he lost and a Floyd fight was never even possible until recently because they were best friends and always said that wouldnt fight eachother. Also Spinks is better then you think and you need to give him more credit for that win. Spinks would beat Margartio.

    Let me explain this thing to you again since you seem slow. Zab was universally recognized as the Champ at 147 when he beat Spinks. He was the guy. Floyd wanted to move up and fight the Champ but it was a new weight and he wanted a tuneup because of the weight and because Zab was a slick Southpaw. Whos the perfect opponent for that? Mithcell. He wouldve never even fought Mitchell if Zab wasnt the Champ.

    As far as Taylor goes, I never said Floyd would win. I just say that its not unreasonable when you look at there styles, even with the weight advantage. Its not like Floyd is a brawler. Floyd wont be right in Taylor's face where he could just stand there and get punished. It wouldnt be as easy for Taylor as you think. You have to also remember one thing about the weight. Weight is a huge advantage but were also not talking about a regular guy. We are talking about the #1 fighter in the world, so if anyone could do it then it would be him and he knows the art of not getting hit flush.

    How is Winky small? Dude has been at 154 his whole career and when he went up to 160 he looked bigger then Tito and looks basically like a natural Middleweight. Also that Winky vs Floyd stuff you talking is false. How do you prove anything by saying that Floyd tried to pull a RJ and take more money? I agreed with Floyd. Floyd was coming from 140 to fight the 1st or 2nd pound for pound best fighter in the sport all the way at 154 after Winky just killed Tito at 160 and you think Floyd is going to do that for a 50/50 split? He would be insane to do that. No one in the world would take that risk and Winky is dumb for asking for that price.

    Winky tried to play it off by saying that he is the one taking the risk by fighting a smaller man and has nothing to gain? How does that make sense? If you are fighting a smaller man that you think you would easily beat then you should take less money. If Floyd wanted to fight Tarver right now, do you think Tarver would say "give me 50/50 because Im taking the risk"? How ****** is that. Floyd was the one taking the crazy risk and he was right to want 55-45 or 60-40. Its not like Winky had a big name like Oscar.

    Now if Winky and Floyd win then Winky cant use that excuse because Floyd will be the same weight that Winky has been his whole career and he wouldve just come off 3 big PPV's with Gatti, Zab, and Oscar. He cant say that he deserves 50/50 because of the weight. Would you think he deserves 50/50 then? That fight wont do super huge numbers so I know Floyd definatly wont do it this time for 50/50 after he has more barganing chips and Winky tried to play him last time. After those 2 fights then Winky would need a Floyd fight way more then the other way around. Floyd would have a ton of big money offers out there.

    Comment

    • Bonafide
      The General
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • May 2006
      • 2233
      • 72
      • 35
      • 9,032

      #42
      anyways...back to the whole point of this thread was that Floyd at middle would be suicide. Even FLoyd is smarter than that. He wouldnt be ****** enough to tarnish his unblemished record even if the money was huge.

      Comment

      • deliveryman
        Your token white guy
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Mar 2006
        • 7592
        • 362
        • 178
        • 15,510

        #43
        Originally posted by Bonafide
        anyways...back to the whole point of this thread was that Floyd at middle would be suicide. Even FLoyd is smarter than that. He wouldnt be ****** enough to tarnish his unblemished record even if the money was huge.
        Offered enough and he would. Money talks, dude.

        Comment

        • moraleskospacisback
          Banned
          Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
          • Jul 2005
          • 350
          • 21
          • 5
          • 398

          #44
          Originally posted by Smokin'
          Yeah, OK. I'm never wrong when it comes to boxing. Care to bet on the Taylor - Winky card? I got Taylor and if you have Winky whoever wins the bet the loser leaves boxingscene for a couple months. We got ourselves a deal?
          lol, thats funny, how u gonna make a bet about something ive never even discussed wit u, ur gonna give me who u want me to have and pick ur fighter and tell me to agree, lmao what a ***, winky is gonna win though, but im not gonna take the bet because there gonna **** winky just like they ****ed hopkins because taylor is there new horse and they want to ride him out, while winkys made it clear he only has a few fights left and hell retire. So winky will win clearly, and theyll give taylor another gift decision. If u want to bet on something bet wit me on the mayweather-de la hoya fight at 154, guarntee floyd spanks his ass, and u said oscar will win easily, so do we have a bet?

          Comment

          • DLT
            DMV
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Nov 2004
            • 17087
            • 737
            • 35
            • 24,277

            #45
            Smokin is just a clown who tries to justify the things he says been calling others names. He just turned 20 but has the nerve to try to give others lessons about boxing. Dude just joined the site a month ago and his 1st 10 threads on this boxing site were about music, so you know this idiot knows nothing.

            He throws out **** and then people throw facts back at him and he makes up a excuse while that **** doesnt count.

            He says Tszyu ran Zab out of 140 and then when people call him on it by saying that Zab has wanted to fight Tszyu ever since the defeat, then he says "well it was a winners take all fight and Tszyu shouldnt have gave him a rematch". OK, how does that add up to Tszyu running him out?

            Dude is all talk and thinks calling guys names makes him smarter then you. Clown!

            Comment

            • moraleskospacisback
              Banned
              Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
              • Jul 2005
              • 350
              • 21
              • 5
              • 398

              #46
              Originally posted by DLT
              Smokin is just a clown who tries to justify the things he says been calling others names. He just turned 20 but has the nerve to try to give others lessons about boxing. Dude just joined the site a month ago and his 1st 10 threads on this boxing site were about music, so you know this idiot knows nothing.

              He throws out **** and then people throw facts back at him and he makes up a excuse while that **** doesnt count.

              He says Tszyu ran Zab out of 140 and then when people call him on it by saying that Zab has wanted to fight Tszyu ever since the defeat, then he says "well it was a winners take all fight and Tszyu shouldnt have gave him a rematch". OK, how does that add up to Tszyu running him out?

              Dude is all talk and thinks calling guys names makes him smarter then you. Clown!

              lmao i agree, dlt just ****ted on u...

              Comment

              • cobracore
                Contender
                Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                • Jun 2005
                • 251
                • 27
                • 1
                • 6,518

                #47
                Originally posted by Smokin'
                And to the original poster:
                You're ****ing ******. Leonard started out at 147 and fought at middleweight. That's MUCH different then fighting from 130.
                I'm ****ing ******?

                Firstly, it was just an idea. It's not like i was saying: 'Mayweather is DEFINITELY gonna move to middleweight and own!!'

                It was a question. I admit my boxing knowledge is not as good as many on this site. That's why i was asking about the possibilities. It IS because i don't know.

                Not knowing and wanting to ask does not make me '****ing ******'. I said it would be interesting to see. I did not say he would beat Taylor. I said it would be amazing if he did.

                So, Smokin. Whats your problem? Why so hostile? It was a question. If you don't think he will, fair enough, but calling me '****ing ******' was completetely unneccesary. It shows your immaturity. This is a boxing forum, to discuss boxing. I asked a question about boxing. You replied, 'you're ****ing ******'. I think your the one who that phrase really applies to.

                Anyways, well, let's see how he handles the weight at 154. If he takes on all challengers, eventually he will have to move up to 154 and if he keeps winning, 160. I think it would be really interesting. If he manages it, we will have had the opportunity to watch a possible P4P all time great.

                Comment

                • Hous
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Apr 2006
                  • 4360
                  • 575
                  • 472
                  • 12,322

                  #48
                  Originally posted by cobracore
                  The greats have all done it. Hearns. Duran. Leonard. Langford. Robinson.

                  Leonard, especially, is a good case. He went from quite low weights all the way to 160 to fight Hagler. Hagler being a great, possibly #1 middleweight of all time. And it was a very competitive fight. (no arguments about who won, thats not the point, i'll just leave it at competitive).

                  Can mayweather emulate this? At 160, could he possible beat Taylor or Wright, Abraham or Sturm?

                  Maybe not now, but when he's older. It would be AWESOME to watch.
                  I dont think Mayweather will be very successful at 154, let alone 160.

                  Comment

                  • ROSEWOOD
                    THE SOUTH STILL HOLDIN
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • May 2006
                    • 4683
                    • 209
                    • 195
                    • 12,093

                    #49
                    Originally posted by cobracore
                    The greats have all done it. Hearns. Duran. Leonard. Langford. Robinson.

                    Leonard, especially, is a good case. He went from quite low weights all the way to 160 to fight Hagler. Hagler being a great, possibly #1 middleweight of all time. And it was a very competitive fight. (no arguments about who won, thats not the point, i'll just leave it at competitive).

                    Can mayweather emulate this? At 160, could he possible beat Taylor or Wright, Abraham or Sturm?

                    Maybe not now, but when he's older. It would be AWESOME to watch.
                    hell no.....say goodbye to that undefeated record if he goes up to middleweight....he will; definitely be limited to just being a boxer...oh and im not so sure he could take a taylor punch...i say hell no pretty boy, stay your butt right there or move down

                    Comment

                    • beezy 14
                      Contender
                      Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                      • Apr 2006
                      • 426
                      • 17
                      • 0
                      • 6,690

                      #50
                      I'm a PBF fan but I think 154 should be his limit like he said in interview's before. I think at 154 Oscar is a tough fight but I see PBF winning on point's, at 160 it would be dangerous against any fighter that's A,B level. He's great and a smart fighter but I don't know if a fighter like Taylor who would know he can't possibly be hurt and has a great jab. I don't like that combination so nothing's impossible but it's unlikely IMO at 160.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP