Greater fighter: Roy Jones Jr or Floyd Mayweather?

[djtmal]

That's your opinion. You're entitled to it and in my opinion you're wrong.

i'm wrong about what exactly...preferring to give full credit to prime fighters who beat prime fighters....

only in the floyd era you have this jankyness...where he fought so few equally great fighters in their prime, that you gotta make up excuses...

[IronDanHamza]

didn't you just say floyd was beating some of the best fighters in the world p4p?

No I didn't.

I said that in regards to Pacquaio.

Perhaps you should read it back.

[djtmal]

No I didn't.

I said that in regards to Pacquaio.

Perhaps you should read it back.

oh...lol........

[IronDanHamza]

i'm wrong about what exactly...preferring to give full credit to prime fighters who beat prime fighters....

only in the floyd era you have this jankyness...where he fought so few equally great fighters in their prime, that you gotta make up excuses...

Every era is the same. Nothing new.

Fighters catch other fighters past their best. Doesn't mean it isn't a good win.

[IMDAZED]

i'm wrong about what exactly...preferring to give full credit to prime fighters who beat prime fighters....

only in the floyd era you have this jankyness...where he fought so few equally great fighters in their prime, that you gotta make up excuses...

Yes, only in the Floyd era where wins over highly rated fighters are taken away because of the excuse that they were old even though Floyd was older.

[djtmal]

Every era is the same. Nothing new.

Fighters catch other fighters past their best. Doesn't mean it isn't a good win.

a good win, hear what you said?...a good win...

Floyd vs. Manny was a good win...

and that is all it is....

school some of these captain save-a-ho-floyd boys on here about what a good win constitutes, and what a great one constitutes....

[djtmal]

Yes, only in the Floyd era where wins over highly rated fighters are taken away because of the excuse that they were old even though Floyd was older.

not taken away, but more put in its proper perspective

[robertzimmerman]

Harder fight doesn't always equal better win.

Maidana was a harder fight for Floyd but his win over Corrales was way better. Could go on all day in that regard.

2015 Pacauaio is way better than 2007 Oscar

Not always, I agree. But the fight with Oscar was really intriguing to me, due to Oscar's skills and his size. Oscar was much heavier on fight night, and I think it was the first time I'd ever seen Floyd completely outsized.

The fight with Manny didn't intrigue me at all. And it's clear from the fight and the tactics he employed, that he wasn't fully fit.

[IMDAZED]

not taken away, but more put in its proper perspective

You can define that excuse however you like.

[djtmal]

You can define that excuse however you like.

you can do the same but i will call you on it you can best believe that