Is Marquez-Floyd the same as ggg-brook?

[Kigali]

Moron, Marquez fought at lightweight THREE more times after the Floyd bout before moving to WW. Thank you for owning yourself and saving me the trouble.

JMM sure as hell didn't KO Pactrash at 135...it was 147.


What did Brook accomplish at MW???

[hhs661]

It's just as bad. Anyone willing to give ggg a pass should do the same for Floyd. If you don't, then yeah, you're ******.

[GhostofDempsey]

Give it up Adolph Jr

JMM stayed at WW and KO'd Manny

Brook did not stay at MW....he's barely scoring KO's at WW

Wrong again shytt-stain. Marquez dropped down to fight Diaz and Katsidis before returning to welterweight again.

[Larry the boss]

Brook was comparably more of a risk. He walks around at 175 lbs. he is a very large WW. Marquez came up from 135, and Floyd didn't make weight for a catch weight that he demanded. Floyd had all of the advantages. JMM was drinking his own urine in preparation for that fight. Look at the size difference when they are in the ring. Marquez looks like a child in the ring with Floyd, Brook actually looks bigger in the shoulders and upper body than GGG.

who is more skilled Jmm or Brook?? all ya'll look at is size..what the hell has Brook accomplished in his career?

[Kigali]

Wrong again shytt-stain. Marquez dropped down to fight Diaz and Katsidis before returning to welterweight again.

JMM did more at WW than Brook ever will at 160

Pale maggot.

[TOBYLEE1]

JMM was exactly that, a tune-up because at that time, JMM did not belong anywhere near 147, especially with that height/reach disadvantage.

While its good he fought Mosley, lets not play like he picked him at his peak. Mosley had a 2 year layoff (longer than Floyd was "retired") and back to back camps after Berto dropped out. Not saying fight would have been better, Mosley was obviously way past it when FLoyd and then Pac fought, but was a bit of a convenient time to fight him.

Shake KOed Margarito, an earthquake in Haiti caused Berto not to fight Mosley and that was the best available fight at the time for Floyd. As soon as he was available the negotiated that fight. True that Mosley was on a layoff and was not at his peek but he was the best available competition

[Larry the boss]

Why in the hell are GGG fans trying to ****ing hard to hype up Brook?? He has one win worth a damn in his entire ****ing career..are ya'll that desperate?? Jesus man Jmm is a hall of famer and was simply a tune up for Floyd..Floyd toyed with the guy...No one else in his entire career has ever done him like Floyd did

[GhostofDempsey]

who is more skilled Jmm or Brook?? all ya'll look at is size..what the hell has Brook accomplished in his career?

You can have all the skill in the world, but if you are woefully outsized it will do you no good. Look what happened to Oscar versus Hopkins. Trinidad versus Jones.

[Larry the boss]

You can have all the skill in the world, but if you are woefully outsized it will do you no good. Look what happened to Oscar versus Hopkins. Trinidad versus Jones.

Jones was far more skilled then Tito,,was that a joke?

And Hopkins was just as skilled if not more then oscar..terrible examples

[GhostofDempsey]

Jones was far more skilled then Tito,,was that a joke?

And Hopkins was just as skilled if not more then oscar..terrible examples

You have lost all credibility, which isn't saying much. Tito was better skilled than Tarver and Glen Johnson...look what they did to Jones. Oscar was a better all around boxer than Hopkins, but he couldn't overcome the size disparity.