Mayweather vs Marciano: Who was Greater?

[Boxing Goat]

the good thing about most LOGICAL h2h's is, no one is wrong.

the ali vs frazier is another triangular concept that gets tested; ali had problems with joe, foreman ate up joe, ali humbled george.

go figure.

Good points. I just think the Klitschko's, Holmes and Lennox were better suited to beat Ali then the fighters in his era, but as you said, nobody is wrong in mythical matchups because we know that that wasn't even close to a prime Ali that Holmes toyed with even if he was still fairly young.

[Elroy The Great]

Lots of people hate Mayweather so that is likely the main reason. Also older fighters get more credit than newer ones. I mean Marciano has been enshrined as a great for 60 years.

yeah. trapped into a certain mindset. thing is, once a rocky fan rolls out the names that are supposed to impress someone, that should instantly wake the up from their dream.

[Elroy The Great]

Good points. I just think the Klitschko's, Holmes and Lennox were better suited to beat Ali then the fighters in his era, but as you said, nobody is wrong in mythical matchups because we know that that wasn't even close to a prime Ali that Holmes toyed with even if he was still fairly young.

yeps.

if a thread is titled ''whos more popular/loved A or B'', ok. but to bring resumes into it.....shameful voting going on here.

[Humean]

Marciano fought and defeated 9 'world level' opponents.
La Starza x2
Layne
Louis
Savold
Matthews
Walcott x2
Charles x2
****ell
Moore

By my estimation Mayweather's count is between 24-29 depending on your judgement.

[Elroy The Great]

perfect how names of voters are hidden. 113 ''fight'' fans would get called out.

[Canelo and GGG]

Good points. I just think the Klitschko's, Holmes and Lennox were better suited to beat Ali then the fighters in his era, but as you said, nobody is wrong in mythical matchups because we know that that wasn't even close to a prime Ali that Holmes toyed with even if he was still fairly young.

I think H2H is not important + you cant check it,but Alis achivments in boxing are great.

[Lou Cipher]

It is clearly Lou Cipher He was even logging in to his old account last night same time this account was posting ..he just doesnt post under the old account anymore....dude is pathetic..he posts the exact same pictures he had on his old account

You ****** ass. Lou Cipher has only one account. No woman will ever be faithful to you.

[Jc8804]

Marciano without a doubt.

[Mr. Objectivity]

the poll speaks the truth. rock was greater than.......................no doubt

[Reloaded]

the poll speaks the truth. rock was greater than.......................no doubt

The poll is a bunch of young newbie fans talking sht as usual , its amazing how the casual fan sees things or should I say dont see things .