Did Floyd beat Castillo?

[-Hyperion-]

I think we have had this conversation before, have we not?

And your assumptions are way, way off. I couldn't care less who won that fight. I don't like Floyd but I'm not a huge ODLH supporter either. Roy Jones and Vitali Klitschko are my boys from that era.

So........

You can formulate a new theory or just go with the truth, which is what I said the reason for starting the thread was.

Oh and BTW, if you disagree with he poll results, fine. Just say that and realize that you are in the vast minority here. That should tell you something.

(Awaiting smart a55 rebuttal.....)

Besides, I already proved to him how ODLH fought Mayweather as soon as it was really possible and he conceded. Yet he keeps spewing the same garbage anyway......as if you can avoid a man who was 3 weightclasses behind you and percieved as too small for most of your career.

These Floyd fans take it as a personal insult to not glorify everything Floyd did or does...

Everytime a poll is made, people think Castillo won...and this dates back to before Mayweather-Pacquiao was even concieved as a possible fight.

[JStill Unbiased]

Floyd won, but what's even more interesting is that these guys are so caught up in trying to pin a loss on Mayweather that they never bring up that this fight with ol boring mayweather was one of the most exciting fights at the time.

[JStill Unbiased]

Besides, I already proved to him how ODLH fought Mayweather as soon as it was really possible and he conceded. Yet he keeps spewing the same garbage anyway......as if you can avoid a man who was 3 weightclasses behind you and percieved as too small for most of your career.

These Floyd fans take it as a personal insult to not glorify everything Floyd did or does...

Everytime a poll is made, people think Castillo won...and this dates back to before Mayweather-Pacquiao was even concieved as a possible fight.

Close fight, but I honestly beleieve the only reason people want to say Castillo won is because Floyd's a prick. Nobody likes Floyd so if you give someone who doesn't like Floyd or his boxing career, a chance to blemish what he glorifies, they're going to do it. These polls are not realistically indicative of what took place. It's a depiction of individuals who don't like him and want him to not be who he say's he is.

[The Big Dunn]

Besides, I already proved to him how ODLH fought Mayweather as soon as it was really possible and he conceded. Yet he keeps spewing the same garbage anyway......as if you can avoid a man who was 3 weightclasses behind you and percieved as too small for most of your career.

These Floyd fans take it as a personal insult to not glorify everything Floyd did or does...

Everytime a poll is made, people think Castillo won...and this dates back to before Mayweather-Pacquiao was even concieved as a possible fight.

Any time a Floyd fan disagrees with something, posters like you act like we are taking it personally. You guys need to get off that stuff.

ODH could've fought Floyd at anytime. He waited until he thought it made the most financial sense.

At least you acknowledge the thread is repetitive.

[JStill Unbiased]

Castillo lost the first 5 or 6 rounds in a row for christ sakes. Give em credit for coming back and making it tight, but keep it real. Put your bias to the side.

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

at what point will this topic go away???????

[Boxing Goat]

Close fight, but I honestly beleieve the only reason people want to say Castillo won is because Floyd's a prick. Nobody likes Floyd so if you give someone who doesn't like Floyd or his boxing career, a chance to blemish what he glorifies, they're going to do it. These polls are not realistically indicative of what took place. It's a depiction of individuals who don't like him and want him to not be who he say's he is.

The fact that he's the highest selling PPV athlete of all time sh÷ts all over the theory that everybody 'hates' Floyd.

[Boxing Goat]

at what point will this topic go away???????

Easily solved. Don't participate.

....done

[Boxing Goat]

Why exactly is it so hard to accept my reason for creating the thread is true?

Example. The ESPN p4p list was made weeks ago and Dan Rafeals opinion is the only one I really care about anyways.

I created the thread a few days after Kellerman commented on the fighter of the era. If I was to somehow get upset about the p4p list or ODLF-PBF results, I certainly wouldn't have waited until now to post this poll.

Go read all my history if you want. I go weeks at a time between visits sometimes and don't go to the forums and look for Mayweather-Castillo polls to see if I'm making a duplicate.

Your accusations are laughable.

[tangalog2200]

I made the thread because of Kellerman's comments on the best of the era.

Nothing race related in here plz.

there is a very very thin link between what max said and what you are trying to point out in this thread....

do you mean max is wrong IF floyd beat castillo in the 1st fight? i don't think so....

even granting floyd won that one, floyd still is not the greatest of his era....