Did Floyd beat Castillo?

[Boxing Goat]

Simple question.

Did Floyd beat Castillo in their original fight?

I say he didn't and deserved to lose.

Vote, discuss. Thanks.

[Boxfan83]

Boxrec says he won. lol but this thread has been made 100x's along with would Floyd beat a prime Julio Cesar Chavez. Seems to me like these threads are made to stir up the brothas and Mexicanz...

[Eff Pandas]

Did Tony Soprano die at the cut to black in the final scene of the Soprano's?

[FrankieClutch]

Did Tony Soprano die at the cut to black in the final scene of the Soprano's?

Where did Jesse go at the end of Breaking Bad?

[Boxing Goat]

Where did Jesse go at the end of Breaking Bad?

To the meth house?

[Boxing Goat]

Boxrec says he won. lol but this thread has been made 100x's along with would Floyd beat a prime Julio Cesar Chavez. Seems to me like these threads are made to stir up the brothas and Mexicanz...

I made the thread because of Kellerman's comments on the best of the era.

Nothing race related in here plz.

[IronDanHamza]

Yes I had him winning.

[The Big Dunn]

I can't recall a thread like this.

I had Floyd winning.

[Johnwoo8686]

Floyd edged out more rounds but Castillo won his rounds by a bigger margin. A fight is won by rounds won not simply by who landed more punches. Castillo's aggressive style combined with HBO's biased commentary is what created the perception the Castillo actually won.

[hugh grant]

Floyd is 49 so Castillo lost. The record books show it