In terms of actual wins, who has the better resume - DLH or Floyd?

[Pugilist95]

And who ranks higher on your all time p4p list?

[boxinghead530]

And who ranks higher on your all time p4p list?

Floyd ranks higher. But ODLH took bigger risks by a long shot.

[Outwest Exp 355]

Floyd ranks higher. But ODLH took bigger risks by a long shot.

He took a bigger risk fighting Hopkins. Other than that Oscar had a physical advantage over almost every fighter he got in the ring with.

[sicko]

I think Oscar ERA was better for sure so I will give DLH that, however when rating them as ATG? Mayweather will always be rated much higher than Oscar no disrespect to Oscar but your bragging about a Resume in which of the big fights he either flat out lost or needed controversial decisions to win them

Yeah he fought Trinidad, B-Hop, Mosley in his Prime but you cannot leave out the fact that he LOST all of them (looking back he was Robbed vs Trinidad though to be fair). Just Saying!

[Divine Hammer]

oscar is more of a hero than floyd.

his wins against whitaker and chavez sr >>>>> anything floyd has done

not to mention he should have wins over a prime undefeated tito trinidad and shane mosley (who was drug cheating).

[Fists_of_Fury]

I think Oscar ERA was better for sure so I will give DLH that, however when rating them as ATG? Mayweather will always be rated much higher than Oscar no disrespect to Oscar but your bragging about a Resume in which of the big fights he either flat out lost or needed controversial decisions to win them

Yeah he fought Trinidad, B-Hop, Roy Jones Jr, Mosley in his Prime but you cannot leave out the fact that he LOST all of them (looking back he was Robbed vs Trinidad though to be fair). Just Saying!

[Luilun]

Oscar Fought everyone in their prime Floyd fought everyone who's a elite when they were wash up. Floyd fought catchweights to drain a fighter or cheat someone at the scales. Floyd used steroids since 2007 which anyone with critical thinking skills can see this only dumb as door knob Floydtards are in denial.Oscar never used Steroids like cheating Floyd. Oscar received one gift decision Floyd received 2. Oscar fought Bernard Hopkins, Tito Trinidad Pernell Whataker 3 who would have handed Floyd a loss. Oscar was robbed in fights while Floyd paid off judges to a sure he wins So I have to go with Oscar.

[RespekonMyName]

I think Oscar ERA was better for sure so I will give DLH that, however when rating them as ATG? Mayweather will always be rated much higher than Oscar no disrespect to Oscar but your bragging about a Resume in which of the big fights he either flat out lost or needed controversial decisions to win them

Yeah he fought Trinidad, B-Hop, Roy Jones Jr, Mosley in his Prime but you cannot leave out the fact that he LOST all of them (looking back he was Robbed vs Trinidad though to be fair). Just Saying!

[IMG]http://media1.*****.com/media/rJ0w60oeJ3Im4/*****.gif[/IMG]

[pasawayako]

If floyd is not using peds i can still say oscar.

[boxinghead530]

He took a bigger risk fighting Hopkins. Other than that Oscar had a physical advantage over almost every fighter he got in the ring with.

And he moved up as he got bigger. But every division he fought in he fought the very best every time out and he took on them in their prime. He never waited to let a fighter lose first before he fought them. Plus he fought in a way way way better era of welterweight than Floyd.