In terms of actual wins, who has the better resume - DLH or Floyd?

[Left Hook Tua]

IMO some of De La Hoya's "losses" are way better than a bunch of Mayweather's wins.

oscar's tito "LOSS" is better than all of floyd's win aside from pac

[LacedUp]

Floyd of course has the far better wins.

Absolutely no question about it.

[RetroSpeed05]

Would Floyd beat everyone on Oscars Resume and Would Oscar beat everyone on Floyds resume? Obv we don't know what would happen just speculate, but imo Floyd would have a much harder time beating everyone on Oscars resume then Oscar would Floyds.

[LacedUp]

Would Floyd beat everyone on Oscars Resume and Would Oscar beat everyone on Floyds resume? Obv we don't know what would happen just speculate, but imo Floyd would have a much harder time beating everyone on Oscars resume then Oscar would Floyds.

Oscar has never beaten a guy Floyd wouldn't also beat. The same can probably not be said the other way around.

[daggum]

Oscar has never beaten a guy Floyd wouldn't also beat. The same can probably not be said the other way around.

whitaker would beat floyd easy. pac was able to land the majority of the clean shots and made floyd come up short time and time again so i shutter to think what whitaker would do to him.

[Mr. Philadel]

Hoya lost mostly all his big fights...Floyd won ALL of his....is this even debatable?

[fourtheboys96]

I hated ODLH back then. But looking back, he really did fought good fighters in their prime.
And except for the Hopkins fight, all of them were competitive.

[daggum]

Hoya lost mostly all his big fights...Floyd won ALL of his....is this even debatable?

hoya fought guys in their primes though. its like saying calzaghe won his fights and hoya didn't. don't be silly.

[Johnwoo8686]

hoya fought guys in their primes though. its like saying calzaghe won his fights and hoya didn't. don't be silly.

No he didn't. Chavez, Whitaker, and Hopkins are his biggest names and they were all old. Mosley, Pac, and Floyd are his only great prime fighters and he lost to all three of them.

[-Hyperion-]

Balco Mosley at 154 wouldve KO'ed Mayweather with that punch he made him dance with. Mosley and Trinidad > any Floyd win(shame Oscar got robbed).

Floyd has longevity on his side, and a stronger resume at the lighter weights. Both at their peaks at 140 or 147 head to head=Oscar win.

Resumes are close. Depends what you like, longevity or prime dangerous fighters.