True or False: James Toney's win over Michael Nunn is better than any win of Floyd's?

[Kagami Taiga]

For the record McCallum and Jirov might actually be Toney's best wins. Floyd for what it's worth would never lose to some of the types of guys Toney lost to, aND that is what sets them apart. But you can argue that Toney's best 2 wins trump Floyd's.

McCallum 1? I thought he clearly lost that one tbh. And the 2nd fight still could have went either way. Toney had a rough time with Mike

[No Tomorrow]

I meant to say 9 rounds not twelve. I know Toney won by KO in the 11th and that the fight was very back and forth in the second half but Toney was well behind on the scorecards. Pacquiao is way more accomplished and was ranked more highly than Nunn was. It's ignorant to call Toney's win over Nunn better than any win n Floyd's resume.

Dude. WHAT are you talking about?

At their respective points in their career Michael Nunn was way in his prime (though him abandoning Goosen and getting lazy with training started to show in some performances - but that's another discussion) whereas Pacquiao was gradually sliding out of his prime for years. That is not to say Mayweather Jr. beating him should be discredited (because it's a great win), but Nunn was more prime than was Pacquiao and was more skilled than was Pacquiao. Pacquiao has great skills, but in no where in his career was he on level skill wise w/Michael Nunn in his prime years between '86-'91

[Pac=Duran]

McCallum 1? I thought he clearly lost that one tbh. And the 2nd fight still could have went either way. Toney had a rough time with Mike

They fought 3 times, terrible boxing knowledge exposed.

[Kagami Taiga]

They fought twice, terrible boxing knowledge exposed.

Dude the fought 3x. Smh hahahaha

[SterlingStained]

these type of threads always illuminate how weak floyd's resume really is despite being "undefeated"

floyd's best win is either:

1. diego corrales, good fighter, not a real hall of famer.

or

2. past prime one armed pacquiao.


just look at his opponents.

name me a bona fide hall of famer who floyd beat THAT WAS IN THEIR PRIME?


ill wait.

thanks in advance.

[Pac=Duran]

Dude the fought 3x. Smh hahahaha

Que? That's what I said.

[Kagami Taiga]

They fought 3 times, terrible boxing knowledge exposed.

Too late now, I got u embarassing yourself. Hahahaha. Go take a break.

[No Tomorrow]

By the way for any one who wants to know :

In 1990 Michael Nunn was rated #3 pound for pound behind Julio Cesar Chavez & Pernell Whitaker

[Pac=Duran]

these type of threads always illuminate how weak floyd's resume really is despite being "undefeated"

floyd's best win is either:

1. diego corrales, good fighter, not a real hall of famer.

or

2. past prime one armed pacquiao.


just look at his opponents.

name me a bona fide hall of famer who floyd beat THAT WAS IN THEIR PRIME?


ill wait.

thanks in advance.

100% dog chit resume. Impressive to go through it undefeated but very uninspiring and always fighting guys at the right time, rather than in their prime.

[Kagami Taiga]

Que? That's what I said.

No. U edited. I clearly posted your first response right after u typed it.