Which of These Two Fighters do You Have Ranked Higher All-Time RIGHT NOW?

[LoadedWraps]

Of course not. Vitali has a huge height advantage over Tyson, throws combinations with mean intentions, and had underrated defense. Vitali is a stylistic nightmare for Tyson.

Tyson also was the perfect size and had the perfect style to counter his height and reach advantage and break him down from the inside.

To me the fight would be similar to Marciano/Ali if they fought because Tyson, like Marciano, would have to get on the inside and force his type of fight, and force Vitali to get into exchanges.

But if Tyson is successful I don't see how Vitali can take the type of shots Tyson would throw on the inside, that right hook coming from the lower level up top would put Vitali to sleep like Prescott did Amir Khan.

[JrX]

Beating a shell of a great fighter is no better than beating a decent fighter that's not a big name



At that point Joe Louis was not a great fighter anymore


Its not just the name but when in their career you beat them is most important


Some of these guys DKSAB

Ohh like Manny past prime, Mosley past prime, Cotto past prime, De la hoya...GTFOh

[Southpaw93]

Manny.

But its close, they are right after each other

[therealpugilist]

Ohh like Manny past prime, Mosley past prime, Cotto past prime, De la hoya...GTFOh

I agree they were all past prime


But none had as many fight as Louis did at the time of his fight w/ marciano or were as far gone as Louis was


News flash genius Floyd was past prime as well in all those fights

All those guys were coming off impressive wins too when Floyd fought them


Louis had the name but lost waaaaaaay more than they did


How about you watch Louis fighting @ age 28 and late 30s and you'll see

[Cinci Champ]

at this point its a pointless debate i mean honestly any none bias person will tell u floyd by far

[SergioMartinez]

Mayweather overall.

Pac had gained and surpassed Mayweather around 2009. But May without a doubt right now.

[LoadedWraps]

Mayweather overall.

Pac had gained and surpassed Mayweather around 2009. But May without a doubt right now.

Good post. Well said.

[BrometheusBob.]

Mayweather overall.

Pac had gained and surpassed Mayweather around 2009. But May without a doubt right now.

Yeah pretty much this. EDIT: If there was debate before, I think the Pac fight has to seal it. Not just because he beat the guy we're comparing him to, but also because that win is probably the biggest on either resume.

[-PBP-]

Hahahahahahahahahaha

Pac has 48 votes

[HanzGruber]

Hahahahahahahahahaha

Pac has 48 votes

[img]http://media.*****.com/media/SkQTm5OAB29JS/*****.gif[/img]