Which of These Two Fighters do You Have Ranked Higher All-Time RIGHT NOW?

[BrometheusBob.]

I think you have to pick Floyd after their fight. Beating Pacquiao is on par or better than anything Pacquiao has done.

Pac was lineal champ of four divisions, his early career is a little slept on. The highlights though would have to be stoppage wins over Barrera, Hatton, Cotto, Morales and perhaps Chatchai Sasakul. First three fights with Marquez were all very close, so I left them out of the highlights.

Floyd Mayweather's best wins would be Hatton, Corrales, Canelo, Marquez and Pacquiao in roughly ascending order.

Idk, I think you gotta go with Mayweather on this one, with the win over Pacquiao being the factor that causes the clear separation. They're both ATG in my book though.

[IronDanHamza]

I think you have to pick Floyd after their fight. Beating Pacquiao is on par or better than anything Pacquiao has done.

Pac was lineal champ of four divisions, his early career is a little slept on. The highlights though would have to be stoppage wins over Barrera, Hatton, Cotto, Morales and perhaps Chatchai Sasakul. First three fights with Marquez were all very close, so I left them out of the highlights.

Floyd Mayweather's best wins would be Hatton, Corrales, Canelo, Marquez and Pacquiao in roughly ascending order.

Idk, I think you gotta go with Mayweather on this one, with the win over Pacquiao being the factor that causes the clear separation. They're both ATG in my book though.

Both of them being ATG's and legends isn't an opinion that's a fact.

Sasakul is defintely one of Pacquaio's best wins and I'd also include Castillo for Mayweather.

[IronDanHamza]

floyd wasn't without a doubt fighter of the year 1998 or 2013. bwaa didn't think floyd was fighter of the year 1998, and ring didn't think floyd was fighter of the year 2013. but pacquiao was without a doubt fighter of the year 2006, 2008, and 2009 according to both organizations. there is a complete agreement there is more legitimacy. both organizations recognize manny as a 3 time fighter of the year.

again ur just fluffing things finding loopholes twisting everything to make it seem like floyd is a 3 time fighter of the year. floyd is only a 2 time fighter of the year. only considered a 2 time fighter of the year with the bwaa and ring and that's how he will be remembered. u and the rest of the farts need to deal with that.

He'll be remebered by most as a 3 time fighter of the year.

But whatever helps you sleep at night.

[Divine Hammer]

He'll be remebered by most as a 3 time fighter of the year.

But whatever helps you sleep at night.

maybe according to u farts hahahahahahahahahahahaha.

anyone can comfortably say that manny is a 3 time ring ANNNND BWAA fighter of the year.

maybe if u farts hope and wish enough he might win fighter of the year this year and be a 3 time fighter of the year according to at least ONE organization hahahahahahahahahahaha. but i doubt he will even win it since he's fighting berto next and his fight against manny was a complete coward borefest.

[HanzGruber]

i was rooting for manny and i will always root for him. so what???????? i knew manny didn't have it anymore and was far past it, but that doesn't mean i couldn't believe that he could pull off a great performance and have the fire again and show glimpses of a prime pacquiao. mosley showed his old self when he pummeled margarito even though he was completely ancient and shot.

Wtf are u even talking. I didn't say you couldn't root for him lol but everyone was saying Floyd was more shot than manny before the fight.

[Divine Hammer]

Wtf are u even talking. I didn't say you couldn't root for him lol but everyone was saying Floyd was more shot than manny before the fight.

this 'everyone' didn't include me u punk degenerate. i said floyd was a coward like i always said, which is the truth. and how can floyd be more shot than manny when manny has suffered MORE WEAR AND TEAR. lets be relaistic. the truth is manny was farr more past his prime than floyd. the facts speak for itself.

[Johnwoo8686]

this 'everyone' didn't include me u punk degenerate. i said floyd was a coward like i always said, which is the truth. and how can floyd be more shot than manny when manny has suffered MORE WEAR AND TEAR. lets be relaistic. the truth is manny was farr more past his prime than floyd. the facts speak for itself.

Manny was probably never as good as Floyd which is why he suffered those KO's and all that wear and tear. Since Floyd turned pro in 1996 Manny and Floyd have had nearly the same number of fights. Floyd has had 48 fights while Manny has had 49. Since 1996 Manny has been KO'd twice, knocked down several times, and decisioned twice (I won't count the Bradley fight). While Floyd has never been KO'd, never beaten by decision, and has only been legitimately knocked down once ALL while facing more world champions than Manny.

It's plain as day to see who the greater boxer is.

[LoadedWraps]

Manny was probably never as good as Floyd which is why he suffered those KO's and all that wear and tear. Since Floyd turned pro in 1996 Manny and Floyd have had nearly the same number of fights. Floyd has had 48 fights while Manny has had 49. Since 1996 Manny has been KO'd twice, knocked down several times, and decisioned twice (I won't count the Bradley fight). While Floyd has never been KO'd, never beaten by decision, and has only been legitimately knocked down once ALL while facing more world champions than Manny.

It's plain as day to see who the greater boxer is.

[Divine Hammer]

Manny was probably never as good as Floyd which is why he suffered those KO's and all that wear and tear. Since Floyd turned pro in 1996 Manny and Floyd have had nearly the same number of fights. Floyd has had 48 fights while Manny has had 49. Since 1996 Manny has been KO'd twice, knocked down several times, and decisioned twice (I won't count the Bradley fight). While Floyd has never been KO'd, never beaten by decision, and has only been legitimately knocked down once ALL while facing more world champions than Manny.

It's plain as day to see who the greater boxer is.

or maybe because pac doesn't fight like a coward punk?? and pac was 17 and 19 malnourished still living in poverty when he was KO'ed early in his career. pac also avenged his loss to morales by stoppage TWICE. truth is pac came up the HARD WAY. he was a big underdog against sasakul, ledwaba, barrera, dela hoya etc. and in pac's prime he was a beast who gave exciting fights EVERY TIME. floyd has been a borefest everytime.

and pac has close to 70 fights. whats with u floyd farts and twisting facts???? trying to say manny has had the same amount of pro fights as floyd??? what sense are u making right now?? hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha.

and floyd should have lost against castillo, dela hoya and maidana was easily a draw if not a win for maidana. if floyd fought prime williams, prime margarito, prime cotto, prime manny, prime mosley etc. he also would have a few more losses too. floyd is a fraud.

[Divine Hammer]

hahahahahahaha another floyd fart supporting a mediocre trash post. all of u floyd wannabe thug life degenerate scums are a joke to society.